Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Am I a jerk for being of the mindset that if you're... let's say ignorant... enough to fall for these scams then you kind of deserve it and shouldn't be reimbursed?
Yeah, if your average 35 year old middle class individual falls for it, fine. If a 85 year old non-tech savvy grandparent falls for it, though, then you are taking advantage of people without the capability to protect themselves. I suspect the latter is the largest source of people that fell for this scam.
[automerge]1582677589[/automerge]
The Boomer generation believes everything they are told.

They grew up at a time when most people had never heard of a scam.
Not quite true. Us Boomers are suspicious of someone who, say, comes door to door selling something. There were many scams perpetrated that way. But we use the computer to get news, check our bank accounts, order airline tickets. We have learned to trust our computers somewhat, and it is easy to let one's guard down.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, my mother-in-law fell for one these scams. She's not stupid, but in her eighties and very far from being tech savvy. As a result, she's an easy target. I suspect many victims are elderly.

My 66 year old mom is not tech savvy at all either but she doesn't fall for scams because she just calls me for tech support. It helps that she doesn't speak or read English so these scams have to be in our native language for even a slight chance for her to fall for it.
 
How to do it wrong ...


Education is far more important than filling the bucket up every time you run out. Make people "aware" of what NOT to do, rather than going along for ride, which is what the FTC is doing. This is as bad as Trump spitting the dummy with bad language when he hates a country.
 
Am I a jerk for being of the mindset that if you're... let's say ignorant... enough to fall for these scams then you kind of deserve it and shouldn't be reimbursed?
Not everyone is ignorant when it comes to a pop-up that says the computer needs service to remove malware. Some people are using a PC, not a Mac, and they may not be tech savvy.
So if my brother asks me about the message and proceeds anyway to follow the instructions, he should learn not to trust everything that pops up on his computer. He ended up taking his PC to BestBuy and may have replaced his hard drive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UltimateSyn
"Click4Support representatives would convince people into providing them with remote access to their computers..."
advice
oh man watch out for allowing someone remote access your cpu
 
Social Security called me yesterday (I'm retired). A legal complaint has been made against both my social security number and my driver's license number. Social Security is going to delete my Social Security number if I don't call this phone number.....

I didn't call.
 
Social Security called me yesterday (I'm retired). A legal complaint has been made against both my social security number and my driver's license number. Social Security is going to delete my Social Security number if I don't call this phone number.....

I didn't call.
oh no xlii you've been unperson'd!!
keep us informed if the picture on your ID slowly starts disappearing back to the future style
:p🤣

its surprising what they come up with sometimes
 
  • Haha
Reactions: victorm1
Am I a jerk for being of the mindset that if you're... let's say ignorant... enough to fall for these scams then you kind of deserve it and shouldn't be reimbursed?

I don't think anyone "deserves" criminal behavior directed at them, but I'm glad to see the org's resources seized and used for compensation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: motulist
What kind of weird dystopia do some of you commentors think we should live in?!

Consumer protection laws exist for extremely good reasons.

No one is getting rich by having a small portion of money returned to them that they were scammed out of.

Vulnerable people don't deserve to have worse things happen to them just because they weren't able to protect themselves from lying criminals.

Even very smart skeptical people can make mistakes and fall for a scam if they're in a moment when their guard isn't up 100%, like if you had just had a couple of beers.

The percent of the federal budget spent on things that *actually* help the people is tiny, it shouldn't even enter your radar. And that's besides the point, since the money being paid out came from the scammer companies, not the government.

-- When the good guys succeed at protecting the innocent, how about we cheer instead of boo?
 
My 66 year old mom is not tech savvy at all either but she doesn't fall for scams because she just calls me for tech support. It helps that she doesn't speak or read English so these scams have to be in our native language for even a slight chance for her to fall for it.

That's the other problem....even on the rare occasion when mom-in-law does call to ask for help, you can't understand what the problem is. She doesn't grasp the overall context that anchors UI metaphors (folders, files, windows, etc) so it's possible to understand what she's trying to accomplish, and this gets her into trouble. And especially when she's browsing the Web--to her, there's no difference between content and ad-sponsored content, she just starts clicking around and following links, regardless of context.

Yes, if it were up to me, she wouldn't be using a computer at all but....you try telling that to my mother in law (or wife). :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.