Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Galaxy Pad--Does it or doesn't it ?

M

Mapmonkey

macrumors regular
Original poster
Nov 7, 2010
121
1
Seoul, South Korea
Ok just a bit of fun here but saw this Galaxy commercial on our local tv this evening.

Now does he actually manage to put this highly original Samsung product :rolleyes: inside his suit pocket or not. On a large screen tv it certainly doesn't look like it. And the scene cuts away before we see his hand leave the device.

Take a look on Youtube link here
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n89q3PddsoQ ------------UPDATED LINK

See what you think.

AND yes I know I can't even think about it with my iPad. One, I wouldn't want to and two, I don't wear a suit.

Seen these things in the store here over the weekend and Steve Jobs is right about 7 inch screens. Too big as a phone/camera and too small to read books or surf the web. If you are gonna get a tablet device get a decent size screen. The iPad size is just right:D
 
Last edited:
7" is pretty cool if you just have a dumb phone, but if you have a smartphone (especially a big one like the EVO or Droid) then I don't really see the point.
 
I'd buy one if it wasn't so expensive. If Apple produced a 7 incher, they could probably do it in the $300 to $400 range. I just don't see people running to the Tab when the iPad costs less and you get more. I would say that it'll appeal more to businesses but I think you'll see that with the Playbook.
 
I read a recent review of this, and saw the video and other review videos.

It looks like it would be quite good for reading e-books, as the somewhat smaller, lighter device has better ergonomics for holding with one hand, and about the same size as a paperback novel. Then again, so is the Archos 70 tablet.

The review I read said that Flash still runs poorly on the Galaxy Tab, so the "full Internet experience" still leaves something to be desired. One other noted drawback was the very limited selection of Android apps specifically geared for the Galaxy's larger screen.

Speaking of Archos: Supposedly, Archos is releasing a 10.1" tablet, the 101, very soon. That seems to me a more direct competitor to the iPad.
 
I don't see him put it in. I see him take it out. At what time point are u referring to?
 
I am going to the T mobile store tomorrow to check them out.

I'm pretty sure it will fit in my pockets though. Especially my jacket pocket.
 
With Apple's desire to constantly make smaller devices I'll wait for the Inevitable 7" Ipad to compliment it's larger brother.
 
i looked at the new verizon holiday commercial....

were a little boy holds and plays with the galaxy tab,

and boy.....that's small....... looks like 2 EVO's taped together....:eek:

looks nice.....
 
Looks like it fit in his suit coat to me, you can see where the outline from it forms
 
reckless2k2 said:
I'd buy one if it wasn't so expensive. If Apple produced a 7 incher, they could probably do it in the $300 to $400 range. I just don't see people running to the Tab when the iPad costs less and you get more. I would say that it'll appeal more to businesses but I think you'll see that with the Playbook.
Click to expand...

The 3G Tab costs a little less than the 3G iPad.

It looks like he puts it in the pocket, but remember, they may have tailored that suit to accept the Tab.
 
Scarpad said:
With Apple's desire to constantly make smaller devices I'll wait for the Inevitable 7" Ipad to compliment it's larger brother.
Click to expand...

I know Steve can always change his mind, but he already said a 7" isn't in the works. Just saying, you may waiting a while. You'd probably be better off waiting until these other 7" tablets get their kinks worked out than waiting for a 7" iPad.
 
Had a play with one in Tesco the other day and have to say for something soo expensive it feels so cheap. The build quality compared to the ipad is poor. The touch screen isn't in the same league as the ipad and compared to the ipad OS the Galaxy Android OS it is more awkward to use.

Apple have nothing to worry about here.
 
Looks like a big Sony PSP to me, only with fewer games. Which is fine if that's what you want, but I think the larger screen of the iPad opens up a lot of possibilities that just won't work well on a screen half as large no matter what the resolution, because your fingers can't get smaller.
 
I can definitely see the 7" working. It looks like a beautiful and well proportioned device for use with one hand. I think everyone can agree with the iPad gets a bit heavy while trying to just hold it with one hand for an extended period of time. I think that the Galaxy Tab is a good first start for Android but Google needs to first come out with Honeycomb before tablets can be optimized for it.
 
mdoyle said:
Had a play with one in Tesco the other day and have to say for something soo expensive it feels so cheap. The build quality compared to the ipad is poor. The touch screen isn't in the same league as the ipad and compared to the ipad OS the Galaxy Android OS it is more awkward to use.

Apple have nothing to worry about here.
Click to expand...
Exactly. I played with this device last Sunday in Carphonewarehouse. I did not see any helpful this tablet can bring to us. 7" can do nothing with normal websites.
 
darngooddesign said:
The 3G Tab costs a little less than the 3G iPad.

It looks like he puts it in the pocket, but remember, they may have tailored that suit to accept the Tab.
Click to expand...

$29? lol


The thing is just too wee!! may as well just stick with your iPhone or whatever rather than bother with a half sized tablet/big phone :rolleyes: this thing only appeals to people who refuse to buy apple products

I have an iPad and love it but while the resolution is good on the galaxy, the screen size isn't good enough to have software take advantage :confused:
 
darngooddesign said:
The 3G Tab costs a little less than the 3G iPad.
Click to expand...

Is there a WiFi only option that costs $499?

9.7 inch iPad compared to 7 inch Tab at about a $30 difference. It seems a bit expensive to me especially considering the robust App store offerings with Apple not to mention iTunes. It seems like a no-brainer.

That's what I meant. What you pay for versus what you get. I think the Playbook will do better. Just my opinion.
 
reckless2k2 said:
Is there a WiFi only option that costs $499?

9.7 inch iPad compared to 7 inch Tab at about a $30 difference. It seems a bit expensive to me especially considering the robust App store offerings with Apple not to mention iTunes. It seems like a no-brainer.

That's what I meant. What you pay for versus what you get. I think the Playbook will do better. Just my opinion.
Click to expand...

its plastic as well lol :p the lack of plastic makes the iPad feel higher quality as well
 
reckless2k2 said:
Is there a WiFi only option that costs $499?

9.7 inch iPad compared to 7 inch Tab at about a $30 difference. It seems a bit expensive to me especially considering the robust App store offerings with Apple not to mention iTunes. It seems like a no-brainer.

That's what I meant. What you pay for versus what you get. I think the Playbook will do better. Just my opinion.
Click to expand...

The PlayBook does look good. I'm waiting to hear pricing and how many developers are going to develop for it. Hopefully they don't make it route through their BIS.

The Tab price is just too high IMO. Another thing thats killing the Tab is very little advertising and Google saying 2.2 isn't optimized for tablets, then you have all the talk about 2.3 and 3.0 it's all confusing for the novice to understand.

I'm going to wait for the tablets to come out in 2011 and also see with the iPad 2 has to offer and how they all compare.

Unless you're getting a tab with a full OS you're going to have to have developers creating apps and also have companies like netflix, hulu,facebook and others support it.
 
Yeah, it almost seems that some of the competition's models are geared for low market penetration. Perhaps the primary goal is to gather market data and find out how people will actually use these devices.

The low visibility, conflicted messages from stake-holders (Android 2.x isn't for Tablets, etc.) and the "statistic" driven rather than function driven marketing campaigns aren't setting the stage to sweep away iPad any time soon.

By statistic driven, I mean marketing focused on processor speed, RAM, etc. Apple has driven iPad by showing it being used for different applications. The Apple commercials never mention processors, ram, or gigahertz. Most of those things don't mean much to consumers anyway.

I liked this Korean commercial more than the US commercials. It was focused on the functions you could perform with a Galaxy Tab. They cheated a little by just naming the use case and saying "Tab" (instead of showing the actual app). They did show him using the ebook reader -- and at the end they did a few stills of what looked like mostly web pages.
 
Syk said:
The PlayBook does look good. I'm waiting to hear pricing and how many developers are going to develop for it. Hopefully they don't make it route through their BIS.
Click to expand...

I really think RIM is gearing this thing to be the iPad of the Corporate World. By example, MIS in my company doesn't want to support another platform in iOS. Essentially, a Blackberry is already supported even if it's a BIG one for all practical purposes. Hahaha. There's really no transition, testing, or development needed.

I think that's what RIM is hoping to cash in on.
 
We have a BES server here too but we're not locked in on BlackBerry. We have a custom app that runs on WinMo but looking to add it to Android sometime next year.

RIM does seem to have the business ear for now but iPad is making strides but by adding a camera (some places won't allow you to enter) and touting flash they seem to be marketing more toward the consumer.

I'm one of the few who likes the 7" design and feel it's more portable for on the go.

The Tab would be on my list if not for the price although I guess it does compare to the ipad 3G version but also will it get Android 3.0. I hear the LG tablet looks to be nice bigger than the tab but smaller than the current iPad
 
As a reading device, the iPad is excessively large. I love it for PDFs, but for books it is not as convenient as a 7" or 6" display. I think there could be a real market for the Galaxy Tab, assuming they price it better.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back