Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I haven't had made or used a single CD in over 8 years besides installing Ubuntu Server cause it doesn't like playing nice with the USB creator. Sorry, CDs are pointless. We have the internet and people like you hold back forcing ISPs to actually provide a decent internet here in the US.

Not everyone lives in the US, nor does everyone have high speed broadband, I don't have a lot of use for optical media myself, equally many do and I see no reason for the technology to be withdraw any time soon. As without any doubts Apple interests in digital delivery are firmly entrenched with iTunes and other online stores as a function of profitability not for the benefit of mankind...

As for your ISP`s holding back, far more likely their greed is the issue, than some still using optical media you might want to give that some thought.
 
I haven't had made or used a single CD in over 8 years besides installing Ubuntu Server cause it doesn't like playing nice with the USB creator. Sorry, CDs are pointless. We have the internet and people like you hold back forcing ISPs to actually provide a decent internet here in the US.

I haven't used them in a while, but only because I have an iodd.. install for most MSDN stuff is on DVD ISOs, as is my OSX OS image, linux installs, etc. - because I can't guarantee that when it hits the fan I'll have internet access to get the machine back. If I didn't have that I'd do what I used to do and have a stack of burned DVDs plus backups in a cupboard.

For the nontechnical buying and using CDs is *enormously* popular, and not many people have access to the kind of bandwidth to stream something like a bluray (it's easy to forget that for many they're happy with their overcontended 2mbps services that struggle with youtube for £5/mo) - although they're likely to have a player in their living room for that.
 
Not everyone lives in the US, nor does everyone have high speed broadband, I don't have a lot of use for optical media myself, equally many do and I see no reason for the technology to be withdraw any time soon. As without any doubts Apple interests in digital delivery are firmly entrenched with iTunes and other online stores as a function of profitability not for the benefit of mankind...

As for your ISP`s holding back, far more likely their greed is the issue, than some still using optical media you might want to give that some thought.
Of course that ISP hasn't done much because of their greed. They realize that oh, people can just get by with "this" much. So if people continue to use optical media there won't be much of a voice to place pressure on ISPs.

Though as people stream more content from iTunes, Netflix and other online services it has forced ISPs to become slightly more competitive. There is no reason to have a physical DVD that can scratch.

I actually built myself a server to backup all my Macs. It's in a RAID 5 so if one of the HDD crash, all I have to do is put a new one in and it's fine. Also I then have my server that backups to a cloud service for server backups.

Yes, somethings must be installed using disc but that's a Windows problem with ISO and it being outdated. I much rather have a strong infrastructure for internet than keep paying for old technology as it becomes increasingly ever more important to have all our content and connecting of our devices as we move around in an increasingly moving world that continues to flatten as cultures mix with the ease of travel.

I much rather have a world where it does not matter where I am that constrains me from for filling the goals, dreams and work I must get done. Having a disc is a problem as it is only local. You may see that as a good thing but I see it as not connecting, non communicating and static, all of which are huge draw backs for me.

Yes you might have to manage your media and learn new ways but get with the times and get connected as it increases knowledge, business and more. Look at how far North Korea has fallen behind because it does not allow its citizen to connect to the world's internet.

Optical drives are not enabling wide spread communication which is why I am against it. Communication is the most important thing. Also it drives up cost. Shipping the disc, manufacturing, etc.
 
Unfortunately your dream is some way off for much of the world, and optical media will remain for the foreseeable. No one suggests we should not move forward, equally we should not strive to cut off those that are not served by the latest infrastructure.

As I say I don't have a great need for a physical drive myself, with much of what I need available online. I spend six months a year working in Borneo, equally others don't have access to the same tech, wireless connectivity, nor do I pay for it etc.
 
Amazingly your GF may have different needs from her computer than you.

Fully agree. There are people like my mother who "never" use the drive (I left a DVD in her computer once and it was still in the drive six months later). Then there are people like me who use it multiple times per week. Different people certainly do have different requirements.
 
I'm surprised there are so many people in this thread advocating a false dilemma: this is not a situation of either the gf gets an optical disk or she does not. she can have an optical disk with any macbook if she *needs* one but that doesn't translate to she must have one *inside* the macbook.

seriously...he's not undermining her authority or autonomy by pointing out the benefits of moving past the notion that one must have an optical disk drive these days to survive in a modern computing ecosystem.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.