Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

caubeck

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Nov 2, 2007
420
10
By pre-caching pages, page turning in Good Reader has become as good as in Fast PDF and United Reader, if not faster.

This is great news for users, not so good for the apps whose claim to fame was speed.
 
GoodReader rocks! I have loaded highly complex engineering drawings (PDFs generated by AutoCAD) and specifications (500 page text PDFs) and it handles them with ease. It eliminates lugging big sets of documents around. The instant page turning makes it even better.
 
I agree, good reader is much faster now, but it still stutters somewhat, and they need to speed up the zooming. Nonetheless, great progress with this new version.
 
Hopefully they are still planning to add CBR and CBZ support.
Still one of my fave iPad apps.
 
I confirm that United Reader is still faster. I have both Apps.
Now I use GR to read text and UR to read graphic intensive PDFs and big files 300-500MB. Zoom is faster on UR too. UR is slower when go backward, kind odd.
UR web downloads is better also. Other than these, GR is generally feature richer.
 
I think we have reached a point at which speed differences become purely academic. I doubt I'll get through a book much faster even if the page turning rate improves by a thousand percent, but it might be good for card tricks.
 
Page turns are still slow for me in GR, I've got some pretty hefty PDF files though.
 
Even though GR is much better, it still doesn't work perfectly on my larger files. I can swipe a few pages but then it hangs while caching. Like it caches a few pages before and after the page I am on, but it doesn't continue to cache while I'm flipping pages so after two or three, I hit a wall and it has to cache again.
 
Even though GR is much better, it still doesn't work perfectly on my larger files. I can swipe a few pages but then it hangs while caching. Like it caches a few pages before and after the page I am on, but it doesn't continue to cache while I'm flipping pages so after two or three, I hit a wall and it has to cache again.

Yep this is what happens to me. I might get a couple pages that are fast, then the next page takes several seconds to load. Honestly I don't see ANY difference in the GR update and iannotate, which does the same thing. At this point I think it's a hardware memory limitation. Seems like GR only caught up to iannotate in loading pages, nothing more.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.