Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
67,482
37,743


Google last week unveiled the Pixel Watch, a Wear OS-based smart watch that has a round display and a suite of health tracking features. We picked up a Pixel Watch and thought we'd compare it to Apple's newest flagship wristworn device, the Apple Watch Series 8.


Since the Apple Watch launched in 2015, Apple has not strayed from a rectangular watch face, while other Android manufacturers have toyed with round designs more like traditional watch faces. Google has opted to go with a round design, and the end result is one of the better round smart watches that we've seen.

pixel-watch-vs-apple-watch-1.jpg

Unfortunately, there are some thick bezels on the Google Watch because of the round face, but Google has adopted a dark UI that goes a long way toward reducing their obviousness. Apple has cut down on bezel size over the years, so you're getting more display area on the Series 8. The round form factor works well most of the time, but it's not great when notifications are coming in because it's a rectangular notification box attempting to fit in a circular display.

pixel-watch-vs-apple-watch-4.jpg

In terms of size, the Pixel Watch is delicate. It's 41mm in diameter, so it feels more petite than the 44mm Apple Watch Series 8. It's more akin to the 41mm Apple Watch, and it's dwarfed by the larger and more feature rich Apple Watch Ultra.

There's a side button and a crown on the Pixel Watch for control purposes, and the buttons are reminiscent of the Apple Watch. The bands are too, with Google coming out with some Sport Band-like straps, among other options. Bands click in like they do on the Apple Watch, with a slide in and twist motion.

pixel-watch-vs-apple-watch-5.jpg

The Apple Watch Series 8 and the Pixel Watch are direct competitors, offering many of the same features. Google has incorporated features from Fitbit, and the Pixel Watch basically does the same thing the Apple Watch does.

It has heart rate tracking, ECG capabilities, and detailed workout tracking with heart rate zones and support for around 40 types of workouts. Emergency SOS is built in, sleep tracking is included, and fall detection is coming later in the year. There is no temperature sensor, a feature new to the Series 8, and while a blood oxygen sensor is included, it is not activated.

pixel-watch-vs-apple-watch-8.jpg

Some of the health tracking features do require a Fitbit premium subscription, priced at $10 per month. You'll need to pay this fee if you want options like the traditional Fitbit readiness score. Google does include six months free, but eventually, some features will be locked.

Battery life varies quite a bit on the Pixel Watch. With the always-on display, it drains quickly, plus there's a feature that constantly monitors heart rate that can drop it down. With those options turned off, it can last for up to 24 hours, beating out the Series 8.

pixel-watch-vs-apple-watch-6.jpg

All in all, the Pixel Watch is a decent smart watch that could one day inspire Apple to offer another display design. You're obviously not going to want to pick one of these up if you have an iPhone, but Android users have an Apple Watch-like device to choose now.

What do you think of the Pixel Watch? Let us know in the comments.

Article Link: Google's New Pixel Watch vs. Apple Watch Series 8
 
I love the look of this, and have always wished Apple would make a round watch.

On the other hand, I don't particularly trust Google with my data, and I really wouldn't trust Google to not abandon this after a few years.
THIS. Google bails on projects 4, 5 years down the line. It's one thing if it's software... But Google's history of bailing makes me very hesitant to invest in any of their hardware.
 
Battery life varies quite a bit on the Pixel Watch. With the always-on display, it drains quickly, plus there's a feature that constantly monitors heart rate that can drop it down. With those options turned off, it can last for up to 24 hours, beating out the Series 8.
Does it beat it the Apple Watch when the Apple Watch also has these features turned off? This sounds like low-power mode for Apple Watch, and that is measured at about 36 hours.
 
"Threat to Apple Watch" - laughable. It's not even a threat to Galaxy Watches. Pixel phones themselves are no threat to any other Android phone much less Apple. All the Pixels sold since 2016 wouldn't even be a tenth of what Samsung sold in 2021.
Most of my Android friends have switched to Apple, and finally acknowledged how superior it is.
Apple, please Do Not release a round Apple Watch, unless it's huge.
My Apple Watch 4 looks a lot better than this Pixel Toy Watch. My next Apple Watch will be the Ultra.
 
The bezels looks like something from Series 4 to my eyes. Kudos for that domed screen choice that give the optical illusion and masks the bezel's thickness.
This is like TheVerge said: it's like Apple Watch Circular Edition. But alas, it's Google with its questionable privacy. And to think that I have to subscribe to Fitbit to get full health feature? No thanks. Apple Watch has it for free it's worth a $350 premium over the Pixel Watch (Apple Watch Series 8 Stainless Steel w/ Sport Band) for me.
 
Round smartwatches don't make a lot of sense. Mechanical watches are generally round because of the mechanism of the actual watch. Smartwatches can make much better use of a rectangular watch face since it is really a computer display. Vertical or horizontal scrolling on a round watch looks particularly ridiculous.
 
In terms of size, the Pixel Watch is delicate. It's 41mm in diameter, so it feels more petite than the 44mm Apple Watch Series 8. It's more akin to the 41mm Apple Watch,

It would’ve been nice, then, to have comparison photos to the 41.

“Really, the times where the bezel looks less than ideal is when you look at those rectangular boxes for things like notifications and just certain aspects of different applications. When you’re trying to fit those in the round form factor, it does look a little bit wonky, but in most applications and watch faces, it looks great.”

Well, you can design some design UI elements to work OK on a circular screen. Others, like text and lists, will look stupid. Nobody wants to read a book that’s cut out as a circle. I guess if you spend most of the time staring at the watch face or compass app, sure. But as soon as you want to, say, configure a workout, type a text message, even just look at a map or a photo? Sorry, it’s just a bad idea.
 
On the photos, side by side, I think the poxel watch looks better. Although I think it's an unfair comparison when comparing an analog watchface with the apple watch's not that pretty digital one. Also, as mentioned above, the bezels are huge, most of that pixel watch looks like a round copy of the apple watch, the square UI elements seem a little stupid and who knows what google does with your data and how long they'll support that thing.
 
Does it beat it the Apple Watch when the Apple Watch also has these features turned off? This sounds like low-power mode for Apple Watch, and that is measured at about 36 hours.
I have only disabled Always On Display on my S7 45mm and I’m at 75% still after 16 hours off the charger. I could easily make 24 hours with those features turned off on a year old battery!
 
I *really* like the look of the Pixel Watch. I know that modern rectangular-shaped UI would look better on a rectangular watch (ie the AW), but a watch is both function and form, and as someone that doesn't interact with their watch all that much, I think a round shape can make a lot of sense from an aesthetic perspective as a wearable item.

When this watch eventually gets heavily discounted, I might try and pick one up. It sounds fairly flawed in its initial iteration, especially considering battery life.

PS I also wish the article would compare the 41mm version of the AW to the PW. Would love to see a side-by-side.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.