I ordered the Photive and the SF matte black cases from Amazon and the Photive arrived first. I really like this case. It looks better then in the pics. It fits with no play and very thin. The bezel is even with the screen which I like since I use a screen protector and don't lay the phone face down. I also like how the matte finish gives the phone some grip. These phone are just to slick otherwise. I was not sure I liked the 2 thins raised lines in the back but now I realize it gives it even more grip and if you use the LED for messages you will be able to see it esp in a dim room. My heart is really set on the SF Matte so I will see how it compares next week. if they are both pretty equal I will swap them out from time to time. For $10 you can't go wrong.