Grill Cheese vs Peanut Butter and Jelly

[Malfoy]

On another board I post on someone brought up this question and it's getting pretty heated. Names are being called, families threatened, etc, so I figured why not bring the thread here and see what develops.

Preconditions:
Both using white bread.

PB&J consists of ONLY PB&J
Grill cheese consists only of cheese.

 

[Jaffa Cake]

Cheese on toast is the hot snack of champions.

A mature Cheddar or Red Leicester is the cheese of choice for such a dish.

 

[calculus]

Cheese on toast is the hot snack of champions.

A mature Cheddar or Red Leicester is the cheese of choice for such a dish.

Red Leicester deffo, although for me it has to be wholemeal bread.

 

[OdduWon]

A buttery crispy Grilled Cheese sandwich is oh so delicious, but some days i would rather have a chunky PB&J

 

[iTeen]

I love both equally... but i voted for a gril cheese cause' thats what i just made myself...tasty thread

 

[Lau]

Ooh, cheese, no question. I had a cheddar and pickle (Branston, not gherkin) toastie for lunch today. A nice variation is Stilton with some sliced grapes.

 

[Jaffa Cake]

By the way Malfoy – you've not shared your preference with us yet.

 

[Malfoy]

By the way Malfoy – you've not shared your preference with us yet.

Grill cheese allll the way.

 

[rockthecasbah]

Grilled Cheese destroys PB&J hands down. Add tomato soup with that Grilled Cheese and you've got the meal of champions.

 

[Eric5h5]

It's "grilled cheese", not "grill cheese", but yes, it's inherently superior to PB&J, which is frequently yucky.

--Eric

 

[mkrishnan]

Grill cheese is amazing, but I don't let myself indulge in it as often as PBJ... Also it's really meant to have a tomato in it, in my world. Although with some tomato soup, I could also be content.

So alas I voted PBJ....

Oh, wait, frack... PBJ on white bread? I don't really eat white. I only eat wheat...hmmm...

 

[mrwizardno2]

*drool* Grilled cheese, all the way!

 

[119576]

Definitely grilled cheese.

I want a toastie now, damn you Lau! (Medium cheddar, ham and beans. yesplease)

 

[JNB]

If you even have to ask, you need therapy.

 

[gauchogolfer]

Grilled cheese for sure.
I think I'll make myself one here soon:
Baguette, grilled with butter and garlic brushed on it
Comte and Gruyere for the melty cheese part.
Perfection.

 

[119576]

Grilled cheese for sure.
I think I'll make myself one here soon:
Baguette, grilled with butter and garlic brushed on it
Comte and Gruyere for the melty cheese part.
Perfection.

*drool*

 

[Malfoy]

Grilled cheese for sure.
I think I'll make myself one here soon:
Baguette, grilled with butter and garlic brushed on it
Comte and Gruyere for the melty cheese part.
Perfection.

+2

 

[VToX]

Besides the fact that I'm lactose intolerant,

GRILLED CHEESE BABY.

 

[psycoswimmer]

Tough decision! okay i actually don't like either...

 

[eric55lv]

pb&j=ewwwwww!
Grill Cheese=taste buds going to heaven with a side trip to paridise

 

[rdowns]

Grilled cheese and mine gets bacon on it.

 

[Oryan]

I just finished a big bowl of tomato soup and now this thread is making me want some grilled cheese to go with it.

 

[Nukemkb]

definitely grilled cheese AND a small bowl of salsa to dip it into!!

 

[Sun Baked]

Quesadilla with some leftover meat, avocado, and a little salsa.

 

[nbs2]

I feel oh so lonely, but I'm going to say PB/J.

There isn't enough information - what kind of PB/J/cheese? If both are done right, nothing beats PB/J on warm toast.

Best. Sandwich. Ever.