Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Grill Cheese vs Peant Butter and Jelly

  • Grill Cheese

    Votes: 84 67.7%
  • Peanut Butter and Jelly

    Votes: 40 32.3%

  • Total voters
    124
PB&J guy. Even better on toasted bread.
PeanutButterJellyTime.gif
 
mmmm toasted peanut butter and jelly with chocolate milk is the best midnight snack ever. actually best anytime snack ever.
 
I feel oh so lonely, but I'm going to say PB/J.

There isn't enough information - what kind of PB/J/cheese? If both are done right, nothing beats PB/J on warm toast.

Best. Sandwich. Ever.

I was very shocked when I saw the results! I don't like GC as much as PB&J. GC is too strong, sometimes. But it's great with some tomato soup.

But I'm sorry, PJ&B (if made right,) is the best sandwich. With Milk.
 
Daytime/early evening/maybe even dinner - grilled cheese, preferably on texas toast with equal parts yellow and white cheese. Also preferably with soup.

Late night - peanut butter on buttermilk or oat bread and an icy glass of milk.

So I vote for both.
 
Daytime/early evening/maybe even dinner - grilled cheese, preferably on texas toast with equal parts yellow and white cheese. Also preferably with soup.

Late night - peanut butter on buttermilk or oat bread and an icy glass of milk.

So I vote for both.

You're the type that calls it soda pop arent you?:(
 
Tough choice.

I like PB&J on toasted wheat bread. sometimes the toast is still warm other times after I make PB&J I put it in the fridge to cool it off for a hot afternoon.

A GC has to have better than cheddar/kraft cheese.

Will not touch white bread.
 
Dang that's a tough one. I absolutely LOVE grilled cheese. But PB&J is also really good.

When it all comes down to it, I can only have two grilled cheese sandwiches before getting sick, but I can have like 5 PB&J, so PB&J wins.

Although no white bread for me-only wheat.
 
Very tough choice. if I'm making it, then hands down PB&J it is. I love the way I make it... either on a toasted bagel, Italian bread, or just plain wheat/white bread. Milk or Yoohoo to wash it down.

Now if my mom is preparing the meal then grilled cheese it is. Because she makes the best GC in the world. Sometimes even add some sliced pickles. What a treat!
 
Grilled cheese all the way!! NO white bread though, whole grain bread (5 grains, flax seeds etc). Fat free kraft cheese, bread toasted till brown :D. Mmmmmm.
PB&J ain't bad either, but no chunky. Smooth PB plus strawberry/rasberry jam is great for brunch.
 
Cheese on toast is the hot snack of champions.

A mature Cheddar or Red Leicester is the cheese of choice for such a dish.

For grilled cheese sandwiches, I prefer mine on 2 pieces of white bread, and I want the packaged "plastic" cheese from Kraft. The 2 pieces of white bread should both be buttered on both sides, and a sandwich press (aka: sandwich "maker") should be used.


PB&J is very good, though. Veeeeery good. ;)
 
I can't even eat cheese, and yet I have no choice but to vote for the obvious superiority of a grilled cheese sammich.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.