Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

Mac GUI Recommendation Needed


macrumors newbie
Original poster
Oct 12, 2011

I have written an image processing program coded in Xcode using OpenCV in C++. I am required to make a cross platform GUI. What would you recommend me to use?



macrumors 68040
Mar 29, 2009

I have written an image processing program coded in Xcode using OpenCV in C++. I am required to make a cross platform GUI. What would you recommend me to use?


Don't do it that way.

Rule #2: Factor out the GUI into non-reusable code – then develop a cross-platform library for the underlying logic

Some engineers think “Cross-Platform” means “least common denominator programs” or possibly “bad port that doesn’t embrace the beauty of my favorite platform”. Not true! You should NEVER sacrifice a single bit of quality or platform specific beauty! What we’re shooting for is the maximum re-use of code WITHOUT sacrificing any of the end user experience. Towards that end, the least re-useable code in most software programs is the GUI. Specifically the buttons, menus, popup dialogs or slide down panes, etc. On Windows the GUI is probably in a “.rc” Windows specific resource file laid out by the Visual Studio dialog editor. On the Mac the GUI is typically stored in an Apple specific “.xib” laid out by Apple’s “Interface Builder”. It’s important to embrace the local tools for editing the GUI and just admit these are going to be re-implemented completely from scratch, possibly even with some layout changes. Luckily, these are also the EASIEST part of most applications and done by dragging and dropping buttons in a GUI builder.

But other than the GUI drawing and layout step that does not share any code, much of the underlying logic CAN be shared. Take Backblaze as a concrete example. Both the Mac and PC have a button that says “Pause Backup” which is intended to temporarily pause any backup that is occurring. On the Mac the “Pause Backup” button lives in an Apple “Preference Pane” under System Preferences. On Windows the button lives in a dialog launched from the Microsoft System Tray. But on BOTH PLATFORMS they call the same line of code -> BzUiUtil::pauseBackup(); The BzUiUtil class and all of the functions in it are shared between the two implementations because those can be cross platform; both platforms want to stop all the same processes and functions and pause the backup.

Furthermore, if at all possible you should factor the GUI code all the way out into it’s own stand-alone process. In Backblaze’s case, the GUI process (called “bzbui”) reads and writes a few XML files out to the filesystem instructing the rest of the system how to behave, for example which directories to exclude from backup. There is a completely separate process called “bztransmit” that has no GUI (and therefore can be much more cross-platform) which reads the XML configuration files left by the “bzbui” GUI process and knows not to transmit the directories excluded from backup. It turns out having a process with no GUI is a really good feature for a low level service such as online backup, because it allows the backups to continue when the user is logged out (and therefore no GUI is authorized to run).

Finally, notice that this design is really EASY (and solid, and has additional benefits) but only if you think about cross platform from the very beginning of a project. It is much more difficult if we ignore the cross platform design issues at first and allow the code to be peppered randomly with platform specific GUI code.


macrumors 6502a
Dec 29, 2009
Though I have never been a fan of how cross-platform GUIs look and behave, I have used Qt and it's actually pretty good.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.