Being a person who had many questions about upgrade swapping and got many different answers, I wanted to create a guide based on my personal experience and how it should actually work.
Scenario 1: Person 1 has an iPhone 2G. You have some random phone and want to upgrade to 3G. Person 1 wants to continue using iPhone 2G.
1. Receive new iPhone 3GS
2. Remove iPhone 3GS from box and activate it on Person 1's line with pre-installed SIM still in there
3. Call ATT, explain to them that you bought an iPhone 3GS on one line, want to use it on your line. Also tell them to switch Person 1's line back to iPhone 2G (If they have no idea what to do, tell them to switch the IMEIs)
4. Confirm which line has what phones/data plans with the ATT representative
5. Remove SIM card from your phone and place it into iPhone 3GS
6. Take SIM card that was originally installed in iPhone 3GS and put it into iPhone 2G
7. Plug iPhone 2G into iTunes and activate
8. End result: Person 1's line remains the same, you have an iPhone 3GS on your line
Scenario 2: You previously had a 3G phone and want to give it to someone after using their 3GS upgrade
1. Receive new iPhone 3GS
2. Remove iPhone 3GS from box and activate it on Person 1's line with pre-installed SIM still in there
3. Call ATT, explain to them that you bought an iPhone 3GS on one line, want to use it on your line. Also tell them to switch Person 1's line to the iPhone 3G previously on your line (If they have no idea what to do, tell them to switch the IMEIs)
4. Remove SIM card from your iPhone 3G and place it into iPhone 3GS
5. Take SIM card that was originally installed in iPhone 3GS and put it into iPhone 3G
6. End result: Person 1's line has an iPhone 3G, you have an iPhone 3GS on your line
Notes: It should still work even if you don't call up ATT and have them switch it, however your line will not show up as using the correct phone
I know scenario 1 for a fact since I just did it yesterday. I am pretty sure it will work this way for scenario 2.
If I am missing any scenarios, or info is wrong, tell me and I'll work on it. Good luck to all those upgrade swapping.
General concepts
1. Whatever SIM card you have in there while activating will become the phone number that you purchased the iPhone on, regardless of what number was on there originally
Scenario 1: Person 1 has an iPhone 2G. You have some random phone and want to upgrade to 3G. Person 1 wants to continue using iPhone 2G.
1. Receive new iPhone 3GS
2. Remove iPhone 3GS from box and activate it on Person 1's line with pre-installed SIM still in there
3. Call ATT, explain to them that you bought an iPhone 3GS on one line, want to use it on your line. Also tell them to switch Person 1's line back to iPhone 2G (If they have no idea what to do, tell them to switch the IMEIs)
4. Confirm which line has what phones/data plans with the ATT representative
5. Remove SIM card from your phone and place it into iPhone 3GS
6. Take SIM card that was originally installed in iPhone 3GS and put it into iPhone 2G
7. Plug iPhone 2G into iTunes and activate
8. End result: Person 1's line remains the same, you have an iPhone 3GS on your line
Scenario 2: You previously had a 3G phone and want to give it to someone after using their 3GS upgrade
1. Receive new iPhone 3GS
2. Remove iPhone 3GS from box and activate it on Person 1's line with pre-installed SIM still in there
3. Call ATT, explain to them that you bought an iPhone 3GS on one line, want to use it on your line. Also tell them to switch Person 1's line to the iPhone 3G previously on your line (If they have no idea what to do, tell them to switch the IMEIs)
4. Remove SIM card from your iPhone 3G and place it into iPhone 3GS
5. Take SIM card that was originally installed in iPhone 3GS and put it into iPhone 3G
6. End result: Person 1's line has an iPhone 3G, you have an iPhone 3GS on your line
Notes: It should still work even if you don't call up ATT and have them switch it, however your line will not show up as using the correct phone
I know scenario 1 for a fact since I just did it yesterday. I am pretty sure it will work this way for scenario 2.
If I am missing any scenarios, or info is wrong, tell me and I'll work on it. Good luck to all those upgrade swapping.
General concepts
1. Whatever SIM card you have in there while activating will become the phone number that you purchased the iPhone on, regardless of what number was on there originally