Handbrake Problem

[Numbers]

Hello,

I have recently begun trying to digitize my DVD collection onto my hard drive. I am using handbrake, but am encountering a problem. The encoding goes over fine, but when I try to play is back in QuickTime, the video stutters and this appears:

http://img101.imageshack.us/img101/2802/handbrakeproblemdy4.jpg

I have tried this in other video players, and the same thing happens.

Here are my settings:

Format: MP4
Codec: H.264
Bitrate: 2500
2-Pass Encoding
Reference Frames: 16
Mixed Reference
B-Frames
Direction Prediction: Default (Spatial)
Weighted B-Frames
Motion Estimation Method: Default (Hexagon)
Motion Estimation Range: 64
Subpixel Motion Estimation: 9
Deblocking: -2
No Fast-P-Skip
CABAC Entropy Coding

Help is much appreciated!

 

[slu]

Are you using the Handbrake presets?

Does this happen to all DVDs or just a specific one?

 

[Numbers]

No, this is a custom setting. However, I am trying it again with the QuickTime MP4 preset. I will tell you the result when it finishes.

Yes, this has happened for every DVD I have tried with HandBrake.

 

[slu]

Let us know how it works out, but I highly suggest using a preset. Especially if you are going to watch these movies on an AppleTV or iPod/iPhone.

 

[Krevnik]

I agree with slu. The problem is that Quicktime doesn't support every aspect of the MPEG-4 H.264 spec. Specifically, a lot of the advanced B-frame stuff. If my memory serves, Quicktime only supports a single B-frame per group of pictures (basically bare minimum B-frame support).

 

[AliensAreFuzzy]

I have actually had this happen if the DVD in question isn't properly decrypted. Try using Mac the Ripper to rip the DVD to a directory and use Handbrake on the directory. Alternatively, try downloading the latest version of VLC to get the proper decryption files.

 

[wingmanmac]

may i ask here...

does anyone know what is the right output settings in handbrake for watching a movie on playstation 3?

ok im too fast, i see how to do it now. - toggle presets

 

[Numbers]

I tried playing the MP4 with the QuickTime preset, but that didn't work.

I'll try again with M4V and the QuickTime preset, as that is the default with the setting. Besides, I looked around on other forums, and it appears that QuickTime/iTunes/Apple prefers M4V over MP4.

 

[bearcatrp]

Try playing it in VLC and see if you get the same problem.

 

[slu]

I think you should try a different preset.

Open Handbrake and click the Toggle Presets button in the top right of the window.

If you don't have any presets, then go to Menu and select Presets > Update Built-in Presets.

I use Apple > Legacy > iPod Legacy

Attached is a screen shot of my setup. I have no problem using this setting in iTunes, etc.