Hard drive dilemma

Discussion in 'MacBook Pro' started by bartelby, Nov 23, 2006.

  1. bartelby macrumors Core


    Jun 16, 2004
    I have a Powerbook with a sick HD. The PB won't start up from the HD and Disk Utility says it cannot be repaired. fsck says the same.
    I, stupidly, have non backed up files on there.

    Would I still be able to target disk the HD to recover files?

    Cheers for any advice

    EDIT: I guess I should add the dilemma:eek:

    Do I:
    A) just go a head and do an erase and install and sod the files
    B) get a new HD and hope I can access the old HD from and enclosure
    C) get a new HD and bin the old one?
  2. mad jew Moderator emeritus

    mad jew

    Apr 3, 2004
    Adelaide, Australia
    Yeah, I find the best way to access a failing hard drive is to boot form another system and access it from there. Otherwise you're using the drive to both run the system + access your files, which is far more demanding than simply using the drive to access your files. Good luck. :)
  3. bartelby thread starter macrumors Core


    Jun 16, 2004
  4. deadpixels macrumors 6502a


    Oct 30, 2006
    if you really need your files these guys can help you but i'm sure they're expensive :D
  5. exoriare macrumors member

    Oct 25, 2006
    Do you know for sure that your HD is sick rather than just the software on it? There are software problems that Disk Utility can't fix and I wouldn't abandon the drive (or the files) until I'd tried something like DiskWarrior first.

    If you think that the HD really is sick then option A will not do you much good. But if it's a software and not a hardware problem then I'd see if I could find a software solution.
  6. bartelby thread starter macrumors Core


    Jun 16, 2004
    The drive was clicking and hanging when launching apps and now it won't start up from the drive.

    I think it's a case of knackered blocks where the OS is sited. So Disk Utility can't repair it as is, but an Erase and Install would work around it.

Share This Page