Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

hajime

macrumors G3
Original poster
Jul 23, 2007
8,184
1,416
Hello, I got the 1st generation rMBP 15" two years ago. There was no problem at the beginning for for the past 3 weeks, I see image retention. Has this issue been solved in recently made rMBP 15". Do you expect the today's announced ones will have this issue fixed?
 
Anybody knows if the just released ones are using the image retention-free LCD?
 
The IR has been solved for a while. Beware of the yellowing issue though that affect parts of the screen,
 
Will this problem get worse and worse?

My (mid 2014, 15" 2.5) screen is an LG, model LP154WT1-SJE1.

Looks fine. Could I find flaws? Probably. However, it's a tool. I intend to use it for a couple of years, then buy a new one. MacBooks are designed to be disposable, and that's the best way to consider them.
 
If you are seeing image retention, it has been reported here that its seems to get worse as time goes on.

Are you sing a desktop pattern that is IR friendly?

I took it to the Apple Store. The guy went a checker board test. He said that there is no image retention. As far as I recall, somebody mentioned that the test from Apple did not show any problem but when he tried his own test, they agreed that there is.

They told me that Apple is not going to replace it for free. If there is an image retention problem, I will need to pay about 1/4 the cost of the latest model to get the screen replaced.
 
I took it to the Apple Store. The guy went a checker board test. He said that there is no image retention. As far as I recall, somebody mentioned that the test from Apple did not show any problem but when he tried his own test, they agreed that there is.

They told me that Apple is not going to replace it for free. If there is an image retention problem, I will need to pay about 1/4 the cost of the latest model to get the screen replaced.

It depends. If you had image retention leaving a checkerboard on the screen, they won't replace it for free.

If you had image retention where windows stayed after a few seconds, they'd replace it.

E.g. they will replace screens which are actually faulty/out of IPS spec, not screens which can be forced into something which is actually a side-effect of IPS displays, under conditions which you would never experience in normal usage.
 
It depends. If you had image retention leaving a checkerboard on the screen, they won't replace it for free.

If you had image retention where windows stayed after a few seconds, they'd replace it.

E.g. they will replace screens which are actually faulty/out of IPS spec, not screens which can be forced into something which is actually a side-effect of IPS displays, under conditions which you would never experience in normal usage.

The Apple store's lighting condition made it more difficult to see the image retention issue.
 
The Apple store's lighting condition made it more difficult to see the image retention issue.

image retention doesn't show up under certain lighting conditions. If there was an issue, it would show up under any light (you could always have held a coat over it or something if that was the problem).
 
Which is the best test to show the image retention problem? The guy in the Apple Store thinks that it might be due to a software rather than a hardware issue!
 
E.g. they will replace screens which are actually faulty/out of IPS spec, not screens which can be forced into something which is actually a side-effect of IPS displays, under conditions which you would never experience in normal usage.

Wow! They really are taking the biscuit here! </sarcasm>

13" rMBP late 2013. No image retention that I've noticed. No idea what make my panel is, and it looks great. No yellowing, lovely cool bright image.
 
Mine just got mid 2014 model 15" no image retention, no yellowish.

Good to hear this (trying to justify to myself getting a 15" rMBP).

If I purchase AppleCare and I see yellow tinting/image retention, will Apple fix it for free?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.