Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Raise to Wake and the new unlocking system are arguably an improvement over the previous iOS 9 unlocking methods, so users may want to try to get used to the new system instead of making the change.

Assuming your Touch ID-enabled device supports raise to wake. My 6 Plus doesn't (for what reason I'm not sure -- battery life?) and unlocking is now a weirdly clumsy procedure that seems to require an unpredictable number of home button presses where none were required before. It's not killing me, but it's hard to argue that it's an improvement.
 
Another reason to stick with 9.3 for now... That and the removal of star rating music... Seriously, it's like they want to screw over my carefully curated & rated 10,000+ song library!
 
I prefer new way but very glad there this option because my mum just cannot do new way instead keep activating Siri. Every. Single. Time.

She just cannot do it and cannot use iPhone. Rest thumb home button option finally she can get in iPhone!!

She got poor thumb control it seem. Lol.
Wow its seriously easy. You press (not hold) the button and leave finger on it (just touching not pressing) for a millisecond. BAM in and at home screen. Like an instant press and it unlocks and enters all in a single step. Not following how so many are having so much trouble with this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bennyf
Wow its seriously easy. You press (not hold) the button and leave finger on it (just touching not pressing) for a millisecond. BAM in and at home screen. Like an instant press and it unlocks and enters all in a single step. Not following how so many are having so much trouble with this.

Yeah I agree it very easy. Me and Dad been try explain to her press and rest finger. Do not press and hold but some reason she just cannot do this. Very frustrating try teach her how do it for hour. Just glad this option is there finally she can get into iPhone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bennyf
Did folks with touch ID and iOS 9 swipe the screen THEN touch the button to use touchID? If so why? Sorry but I am failing to see how this is so much more difficult and trying to understand how folks are missing the slide to unlock. I cant remember when I used that other than after phone was rebooted and I had to enter a code since iOS 8 and iPhone 6.
[doublepost=1473884678][/doublepost]
Yeah I agree it very easy. Me and Dad been try explain to her press and rest finger. Do not press and hold but some reason she just cannot do this. Very frustrating try teach her how do it for hour. Just glad this option is there finally she can get into iPhone.
LOL i hear ya. This does solve it if they mastered iOS 9 No press needed at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bennyf
First thing I did was enable this and disable raise to wake. I was quite happy with my phone'a unlocking behavior in iOS 9 and am glad Apple left us a way to stick with what works.
 
I hate this new design for several reasons.

(1) Pressing the home button is awkward; swiping is natural. They should have left an option to swipe to unlock even with the "wake on rise" mode on.

(2) I don't want my notifications showing before the device is unlocked. What is the point of having a password and a thumbprint lock if anyone can see notifications as they come into the phone? I don't want to have to go through the extraordinarily kludgy process of, one by one, selecting all of my 500+ apps and manually setting them to not send notifications to the home screen.

(3) Notifications have never been done very well in iOS. I greatly prefer how it was in the Palm Pre, where a notification would remain on the screen in unlocked mode until it was dismissed, rather than only popping up briefly before disappearing. That way I could leave something on the screen until I had time to deal with it, and it would keep reminding me to deal with it because it was still there on my screen until I dismissed it. I hate having to swipe down into the Control center thing, then scroll through a list of 400 majillion notifications from every freaking app, since nowadays they ALL want to constantly spam you with crap like eBay saying "New Items are now on eBay! Come look!" (Well no crap, Sherlock!) Or Future Music: "Get up to 89 issues of Future music for just $47.99" or Sleep Cycle "Good Morning!" etc. I hate all that!

(4) There should be an option to show the notifications screen immediately after unlock as the homepage of the phone, rather than always showing me the apps screen first. The apps screen is basically useless; it hasn't been changed since they added app folders, but app folders are a huge pain in the butt to use because you have to drag an app across 12 screens of other apps and folders, and if you drop it in the wrong place (which is easy to do) then it will screw up the app tiling on all the subsequent pages! Why have they still not added the ability to long-press on an app and then be shown a list of all folders and pages on the device (like the screen you see in iTunes) so that you can send an app directly to the proper folder? Why don't they have the ability to select which folder an app will go into when you download it from the App Store the first time?! Why does it always dump in on whatever the first page with an open slot was? I was keeping those slots open FOR A REASON, so that if I accidentally drop an app somewhere, there is some buffer space and every subsequent page won't get all screwed up!

Come on Apple! Where is your brain these days?
Wow, what a wall of text. But what really bothers me most: 500 apps? What for? What. For?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keane16
No raise to wake on my 6 Plus so this isn't an issue for me, but I can see how it would be with a newer iPhone.

Apple love to monkey with power button function with every OS release. My Mac Pro's power button always is "enhanced" after every new OS X version.
 
I usually don't modify features that are new and give myself a few months to deal with them. A lot of colleagues modified their Macs to disable the "natural scrolling" introduced a few years ago. Im' so glad I stuck with it because scrolling up to go down just makes more sense and is much more natural. Eventually, this will become natural as well. If the home button goes away next year, I'll be glad I kept this behavior.
I don't get how this will help in the future. This step makes you click the home button to enter your phone...supposedly the new phones won't have a home button. So basically, you're re-learning to click a button that will eventually disappear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AngerDanger
My fingers must sweat too much or are too rough -- I don't think touch id was designed for people who do much work with their hands. Anyway, as someone who has re-added their fingerprints to the phone about once a month... push-to-unlock creates a frustrating degree of uncertainty. There's the one little message at the bottom that indicates whether my fingerprint has been read yet, but even that message has a built in lag since the phone will sometimes go to the home screen prior to that message changing.

So I end up resting finger on button, waiting, pressing the button (buzz! denied), re-position finger, wait, rub finger on shirt, rest on button, press button (buzz!! haha sucker!)... passcode required to unlock phone... swear under my breath, type in passcode. This is iPhone 6. 6s touchid on wife's phone was programmed once and works 99% of the time.

Long story short, this new behavior might work well on the latest edition touch id, but it kind of sucks on earlier versions.

(I have lock-screen only notifications that I don't want to miss, so I don't want to change the setting. And I don't like having the same notification in more than one place for some reason.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: canucksfan88
Assuming your Touch ID-enabled device supports raise to wake. My 6 Plus doesn't (for what reason I'm not sure -- battery life?) and unlocking is now a weirdly clumsy procedure that seems to require an unpredictable number of home button presses where none were required before. It's not killing me, but it's hard to argue that it's an improvement.
Are you using TouchID?
 
I don't get how this will help in the future. This step makes you click the home button to enter your phone...supposedly the new phones won't have a home button. So basically, you're re-learning to click a button that will eventually disappear.

but the next phone allegedly will require the user to push down even if the button itself
 
I guess I was already accustomed to pressing home button to wake device. Already prefer hitting home button to unlock.
 
I think their end game is to try to provide as consistent an experience as possible. Having some be slide to unlock, and not have the widget screen, would have been a pretty bad experience.



Except Aero on older machines made them unusable. They're not anything alike.


Only an Apple sycophant could believe the above to be a valid argument. The user experience is between the user and the device. If the user isn't having a good experience because they don't have Touch-ID device and it's more difficult to open the device then Apple isn't providing a good experience in that instance.

Also, the user to a large degree defines the experience they want by customizing the settings --- what ring tone to play, what notifications to recieve and in what manner, big type, little type, motion home screen on/off, etc, etc. If the user OPTS to forgo widgets for the swipe to open then that is what makes it a better experiece for them. Just because you enjoy widgets doesn't mean someone else doesn't prefer swipe to open more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: markieG84
Hah oh great, first I'll start a letter writing campaign to Microsoft to make them aware that they in fact own Skype, and what Skype is, and supposed to do, and then see if we can get them to find a guy to put together a committee to determine if writing an update for it someday would be something they should put on a list, and file in the back of one of those pea green file cabinets from the 60's and then immediately lose the keys to it.
 
This works well.

Now...

When I'm on my first page.... The home button does nothing. Except get me to the first page if I wasn't on that screen. My page!

Could you apple people please make it so that *one* press brings up the app switcher!

Do something, the button is redundant on our home page.

Though, loving the three click options in Accessibility. Being able to invert the colours on my phone like pressing command-option 8 on a Mac is bloody sublime.
 
I am surprised how many don't like the click to unlock. Oh well.
Compared to the previous implementation, it requires an extra step. If for instance a notification came in an woke up the iPhone, I could rest my finger on the home button and the phone would unlock. But now I have to click the button and rest my finger afterward. It doesn't seem like a big deal, but the experience doesn't feel as seamless. I'm glad there's a way to re-create the previous method, especially now that we have the new raise-to-wake feature.

I can see where Apple is heading with this, though. Since the iPhone 7 doesn't have a clickable Home button, all you're doing is bearing down a little harder on the bezel to unlock the phone. When that button disappears completely, the "click to open" idea will no doubt make more sense.
 
I hate this new design for several reasons.

(1) Pressing the home button is awkward; swiping is natural. They should have left an option to swipe to unlock even with the "wake on rise" mode on.

(2) I don't want my notifications showing before the device is unlocked. What is the point of having a password and a thumbprint lock if anyone can see notifications as they come into the phone? I don't want to have to go through the extraordinarily kludgy process of, one by one, selecting all of my 500+ apps and manually setting them to not send notifications to the home screen.

(3) Notifications have never been done very well in iOS. I greatly prefer how it was in the Palm Pre, where a notification would remain on the screen in unlocked mode until it was dismissed, rather than only popping up briefly before disappearing. That way I could leave something on the screen until I had time to deal with it, and it would keep reminding me to deal with it because it was still there on my screen until I dismissed it. I hate having to swipe down into the Control center thing, then scroll through a list of 400 majillion notifications from every freaking app, since nowadays they ALL want to constantly spam you with crap like eBay saying "New Items are now on eBay! Come look!" (Well no crap, Sherlock!) Or Future Music: "Get up to 89 issues of Future music for just $47.99" or Sleep Cycle "Good Morning!" etc. I hate all that!

(4) There should be an option to show the notifications screen immediately after unlock as the homepage of the phone, rather than always showing me the apps screen first. The apps screen is basically useless; it hasn't been changed since they added app folders, but app folders are a huge pain in the butt to use because you have to drag an app across 12 screens of other apps and folders, and if you drop it in the wrong place (which is easy to do) then it will screw up the app tiling on all the subsequent pages! Why have they still not added the ability to long-press on an app and then be shown a list of all folders and pages on the device (like the screen you see in iTunes) so that you can send an app directly to the proper folder? Why don't they have the ability to select which folder an app will go into when you download it from the App Store the first time?! Why does it always dump in on whatever the first page with an open slot was? I was keeping those slots open FOR A REASON, so that if I accidentally drop an app somewhere, there is some buffer space and every subsequent page won't get all screwed up!

Come on Apple! Where is your brain these days?

1) It's not natural, it's learned. Sometimes it's worth learning a new way (for example coming from Windows to MacOS).
2) Thats why you can disable them in the options. Nothing new there.
3) That's not a criticism of the new design - it's never been how you describe.
4) I agree. Seems like all the pieces are in place now - the notification screen is the first thing you see before you click the home button, all they need to do is let you set it so the screen is blank until you rest your finger on the button, which would then unlock it and show your notifications, but still wouldn't take you to the home screen until you click. It's *almost* exactly how it works now, would be such a minor change for them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keane16
I put the new way back on and I'm already used to it.

Highly recommended if you have raise to wake...
 
I guess I was already accustomed to pressing home button to wake device. Already prefer hitting home button to unlock.
I was about to ask those who are complaining, how did they wake the device before?
Compared to the previous implementation, it requires an extra step. If for instance a notification came in an woke up the iPhone, I could rest my finger on the home button and the phone would unlock. But now I have to click the button and rest my finger afterward. It doesn't seem like a big deal, but the experience doesn't feel as seamless. I'm glad there's a way to re-create the previous method, especially now that we have the new raise-to-wake feature.

I can see where Apple is heading with this, though. Since the iPhone 7 doesn't have a clickable Home button, all you're doing is bearing down a little harder on the bezel to unlock the phone. When that button disappears completely, the "click to open" idea will no doubt make more sense.
See thats the thing, it does unlock with a touch not button press. With the default setting a finger rest and the lock screen unlocks so you can interact with the notifications and such. A press of the home button takes you to the home screen. With this setting off, watch up top in status bar. There is a locked lock, rest finger and you will see the lock unlock but you will still be on the lock screen. If just interacting with the locked screen stuff you can do so. If you then press the home button you will go directly to the home screen. With this setting enabled you basically bypass the lock screen items. So if you dont really want to interact on the lock screen, this is the way to go. But if you DO tend to use the lock screen widgets then this setting is best if its off typically.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zhenya
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.