Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

subq

macrumors member
Original poster
Oct 18, 2008
70
0
Any recommends on portable hd's for new macbook (no firewire) and time machine?

The WD passports are terrible in regards to reliability.
 
If I didn't have a good working external drive right now, I'd consider a Time Capsule for the whole house to use (5 Macs).
 
Any recommends on portable hd's for new macbook (no firewire) and time machine?

The WD passports are terrible in regards to reliability.

I just bought a Time Capsule 500G and attached my other 500G to it. Pretty sweet.

Joshua.
 
Does it have to be "portable" as in 2.5" HDD? If not, I always like to build my own. I like the Macally External cases with Seagate Barracuda drives.

Macally also makes 2.5" enclosures, but they don't look as slick as the MyBook, FreeAgent, and Passport OEM drives.

I have lots of Macally cases in many flavors. I just bought a 2.5" enclosure (PHR-S250CC) with a SATA interface and USB/FW ports. Works great.
 
I only have one Mac so I just took an extra HDD that I had in my old desktop PC and put it in an enclosure, it's a 160gb drive. It's good enough for now. I wanted my 1TB drive to be my back up drive but it won't spin up, time to RMA it!
 
The WD passports are terrible in regards to reliability.

This may be the case. However if it is just a backup (not the sole copy of files), wouldn't it be less of an issue?

Anyway, I use the WD My Book drives. They are quite - no low fan noise, just the normal HDD clicking. Also, it has auto on/off - one less switch to manage when I connect/disconnect.

In contrast, many external drive enclosures have a power button, with a noisy fan.
 
I only have the macbook that I need to back up.

I would love to back it up to the NAS on the network but I have to hack it for time machine to do that I believe.

Maybe I will just buy an enclosure and use something other than WD for the drive.
 
after running the numbers it is almost worth it to just get the time capsule or airport extreme (I use an airport express now so I can't hook a HD into it for time machine over the air)

I imagine airport extreme would be more flexible as long as I could backup with time machine over the air...does that work? I had read they removed that feature or something (but that was a long time ago).
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.