So, I have been able to narrow it down to three cases but I still need some help in figuring out which will work best. Case #1: Speck Candyshell, I like the protection that it will give, but it is bulky. Case #2: Switcheasy Capsule Neo, I really like the black one it looks awesome. It doesn't seem to be as bulky as the candyshell but not sure on the protection. I'm also worried about that paper thin membrane that is put on first, it seems like it will tear very easily. Case #3: Switcheasy Torrent, Looks very nice and seems like it is a very simple case, but not sure about the main skin on the phone, seems like it would be sticky when your moving your phone in and out of your pockets. Another plus with the Switcheasy cases is the fact that you get so much stuff. I especially like the plugs that you get. Does anyone know if the adhesive screen protectors that you get with all of these cases will damage the coating that is on the screen of the 3gs? Thanks ahead of time!