Assuming u mean the candyshell not in the grip version, I'd definitely recommend the incipio DualPro but not the shine, the edge version. This one has some grip. But not too much and doesn't attract that much lint either. The symmetry is really nice but the back is slippery and adds no grip. The candyshell will scratch even before you put it on ur phone and is slippery as well. I'd definitely recommend the candyshell grip over all 3 that u listed with the DualPro edge second.