Anyone have experience with this? My father in law switched to AT&T 6 months ago. He bought a 2 person family plan and got the $200 subsidized iPhone 4 for himself. I gave my old iPhone 3G to his wife and she used that. Got it so far? He pays for 2 iPhone plans on a family plan but only bought 1 phone from them. So now he's considering buying his wife an i4 and figured he could get the subsidized price for her. I thought so too and said so when he asked me. But today AT&T told him that she's not eligible because she (through him) signed up for a 2 year contract and can't get a subsidized phone until 2012. So I ask you: When did AT&T change it so that you can only get ONE subsidized iPhone with a 2 person family plan? Did they make that change? Or are they just lying to him? He's already done the "argue with them on the phone" thing. It would help if we had something specific on their website to point to. Or are we wrong? Do 2nd family members not get subsidized iPhones anymore? Thanks in advance for any advice.