Help needed: Storage

Hey Mac peeps,

I believe that the vast majority of you have at least some form of external storage. The HDD space that comes with your Mac, short of the mac pro, should not be sufficient right?

Because I am using an iMac, the non user-upgradability forces one to resort to external drive solutions. In the past, when my storage requirements were lower, 1 or 2 enclosures each housing a single drive would suffice. However, I realized that as my storage needs grew, I could not continually add more drives via enclosures each housing an individual drive.

This is not a viable option in the long run. I look set to purchasing 2 more external HDDs. Since the iMac comes with only 3 USB2.0 ports, I would definitely have to use them in conjunction with a USB hub.

• Is it silly to connect 5 external HDDs in their respective enclosures to the Mac through a USB hub?
• Does using several external HDDs connected to a USB Hub slow down performance?

There would be too many enclosures, each requiring their own power point. Some had to be (I naively bought USB2 enclosures as they were cheaper) connected through hubs. Moreover, it made for crazy cable management on my table. Lastly, I am not sure if I have been pursuing the right storage solution.
I look to use my external storage as a

• Backup solution. I plan to use SuperDuper! to store a clone of my hard disk.
• Music storage. The iTunes music library would be housed externally as the current size of my music library negates the meagre size of my existing internal hard disk.
• Media storage. Videos, TV shows, Movies, Ripped DVDs, Video Podcasts and the like.
• If possible, I would like the above media to be accessible from other Macs in the household via the wireless-G network I have at home.

While the accessibility from other Macs is nice, speed is important too. Currently, USB2 does not cut it. For example, I wanted to transfer the contents on one drive to another; it was around 100GB and it took more than a day!

• My media collection is already very large. Do you guys actually make a backup copy of your media collection? I am not referring to precious photos but your mp3 and video collection.
• Is replacing all my enclosures with FireWire ones and then daisy-chaining them a viable solution?
• I have read up about RAID but am still confused. Do I need it?
• What are the setups that you guys have? I’m open to anything. I just hope that it would not involve spending too much money cause I don’t have that much to spend.

I would really like to hear from you guys.

Thanks all!

 

Hi, thanks for the reply!

Correct me if I am wrong. As my house does not allow for the implementation of a wired network, this NAS would be connected via my wireless-G network. The speeds max would be 54mbps.

This is good as all the Macs/Windows boxes can access it. However, I have tried transferring files via a wireless network and it is rather slow. Moreover, I wish to perform backups/clones of my Macintosh HD to the HDD via SuperDuper!. Therefore, I figure that the connection speed has to be rather fast.

How do people utilize their NAS? Do they all use Gigabit Ethernet?

 

Yes, you are entirely right! I was pleasantly surprised when I used my pal's FireWire enclosure. It was so much faster than USB2.

The existence of USB2 enclosures in my set-up stems from the fact that I had just switched from a Windows-centric environment, where FireWire was far and few between.

Yes, i think FireWire is the way to go. However, my 20' iMac comes with FW400. Do you think that will suffice? I intend to transfer data between external HDDs.

Hmm, you mean get an enclosure that is hot-swappable? Where I can insert and remove disks freely? I would prefer a solution that requires less user intervention.

 

matticus008,

I have considered a network solution.

Actually, the Airport Extreme router looks like a good solution. It can share printers and hard drives connected to a USB hub that is connected to the single USB2 port on it.

However, my gripe is, correct me if I am wrong, that unless all the Macs/Windows boxes in my household have wirelss-N, if not, the speed of the network would be downgraded to the lowest wireless standard on the network. That is, if I have an old Powerbook/Thinkpad with wireless-G, the speeds would go back down to 54mbps?

I have tried transferring files over a wireless network and found it slow and unreliable. Sometimes, transfers would disconnect or stop halfway. From your experience, it seems okay. Hmm, perhaps it is because the computer is set-up solely to be a server? What is it? A tall Windows/Linux tower?

Also, I do not have a wired network and thus Gigabit Ethernet is not an option to me. Moreover, the Airport Extreme comes with only 10/100, I think, which means it does not support 1000mbps. But on hindsight, from what I have learnt from you, 100 is enough.

Thanks a lot!

 

Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!