Home Button Loose/Deeper

crimsontide165

macrumors member
Original poster
Feb 5, 2011
35
0
Just got the "new" iPad and it's really awesome, however the home button feels deeper and I can feel the edges of glass. Could it be messed up or is this normal? I have a 4s that feels fine I'm just wondering if it's suppose to be like this/deeper in on the iPad.
 

xMBPx

macrumors regular
Dec 29, 2010
181
1
Just got the "new" iPad and it's really awesome, however the home button feels deeper and I can feel the edges of glass. Could it be messed up or is this normal? I have a 4s that feels fine I'm just wondering if it's suppose to be like this/deeper in on the iPad.
Sucks mate, not normal obviously. My home button is perfect. However, apple will claim that certain variations are normal, however unideal they are. I got the same run around with the home button on my iPhone.

Wish they would eliminate the button aspect sometimes for that reason and make it pressure sensitive. One less breaking point to worry about.
 

xkmxkmxlmx

macrumors 6502a
Apr 28, 2011
883
114
Just got the "new" iPad and it's really awesome, however the home button feels deeper and I can feel the edges of glass. Could it be messed up or is this normal? I have a 4s that feels fine I'm just wondering if it's suppose to be like this/deeper in on the iPad.
I just posted about mine not being as responsive as my iPhone or iPad 2. Now that I rub my finger across, it does feel a bit deeper than the others.

Sucks.
 

seasurfer

macrumors 6502a
Dec 12, 2007
648
130
I have the same problem, I just got mine from Apple store, do you think they will change it?
 

xkmxkmxlmx

macrumors 6502a
Apr 28, 2011
883
114
I have the same problem, I just got mine from Apple store, do you think they will change it?
I have read that they will exchange it but they won't give you the new one until they have them available. Or you can just return or get credit.

Try calling them to make sure.
 

bob.loblaw

macrumors member
Feb 26, 2010
89
0
Mine actually sticks up above the glass a little. The button click action and sound is different across 3 iPads and 2 iPhones I use on a regular basis.
 

pmz

macrumors 68000
Nov 18, 2009
1,948
0
NJ
Mine actually sticks up above the glass a little. The button click action and sound is different across 3 iPads and 2 iPhones I use on a regular basis.
Mine is a little higher too. However I find thee action of the button to be softer and shorter. It's nice. I barely use the HB with all the gestures though.

Not worth complaining about.
 

bryanc28

macrumors 6502
Dec 7, 2007
336
47
Arlington, Va
Just got the "new" iPad and it's really awesome, however the home button feels deeper and I can feel the edges of glass. Could it be messed up or is this normal? I have a 4s that feels fine I'm just wondering if it's suppose to be like this/deeper in on the iPad.
Most of the iPad 2's home buttons in the store all felt like this. It's awful. I was given a refurb unit last Xmas & the home button is so smooth. I would exchange it as it would just annoy the heck out of me.
 

seasurfer

macrumors 6502a
Dec 12, 2007
648
130
I went back to change it, they don't have the white iPad, so they me the black one. A dented home button is very annoying.
 

Mobster1983

macrumors 6502a
Sep 8, 2011
627
446
Mine and my girlfriends are both the same. The home button is depressed slightly into the glass and you can SE it's not flush with the screen. There is even a slight space between the side of the glass and about 1/4 of the home button.

I'm not too worried about it for now since it doesnt seem to affect the functionality and I don't want to wait three weeks for a replacement.
 

Daniel97

macrumors 6502a
Mar 6, 2011
719
2
You guys are pathetic.

Swap your iPad because you don't like how the button feels?

Sme people are NEVER happy! Think yourself lucky you have one!
 

crimsontide165

macrumors member
Original poster
Feb 5, 2011
35
0
You guys are pathetic.

Swap your iPad because you don't like how the button feels?

Sme people are NEVER happy! Think yourself lucky you have one!
Pathetic? For what? being annoyed by a loose and deep button on something
we just payed over $800 gives us every right to want to swap it out.
 

seasurfer

macrumors 6502a
Dec 12, 2007
648
130
Pathetic? For what? being annoyed by a loose and deep button on something
we just payed over $800 gives us every right to want to swap it out.
Totally agree. The home button being deep is a legitimate issue, it does make the finger feels uncomfortable.
 

AAPLFAN

macrumors member
Oct 12, 2011
39
0
Mine creaks when I lightly slide my finger across it. Same thing if I lightly touch all around the home button. When I depress on it the button works but you can hear the extra creak before the click. Seems like the button is not centered or loose and not flushed. None of the other 2 ipad 2s and 2 iphones has this issue.

Should I bother to try to go to a store and exchange it? It does not seem like it will affect normal operation just a little irritating right now since it is new out of the box.
 

LanEvo

macrumors 6502
Sep 5, 2010
434
2
NorCal
Mine creaks when I lightly slide my finger across it. Same thing if I lightly touch all around the home button. When I depress on it the button works but you can hear the extra creak before the click. Seems like the button is not centered or loose and not flushed. None of the other 2 ipad 2s and 2 iphones has this issue.

Should I bother to try to go to a store and exchange it? It does not seem like it will affect normal operation just a little irritating right now since it is new out of the box.
Mine is like this too, but the screen is almost perfect. So I will not bother with it. I have 1 yr. to ponder it.
 

shortcut3d

macrumors 65816
Aug 24, 2011
1,112
15
I have torn down the iPad 2 (not crazy enough to do my new iPad) and the home button assembly is actually bonded to the glass with 3M adhesive. The bottom of the button is directly affixed to the screen. If this separates then the button will sit deeper and feel clicky.
 

AAPLFAN

macrumors member
Oct 12, 2011
39
0
Mine is like this too, but the screen is almost perfect. So I will not bother with it. I have 1 yr. to ponder it.
Thanks good to know. I am in your camp. Hate to exchange it due to a small issue and get a worse one. Plus not sure what is the stock level at Apple stores in Socal.

My ipad 2 has more light bleeds than some of those shown on this forum but it did not bother me since I don't watch movies in the dark and told myself I have one year to ponder it. Guess one year is up and I am keeping it haha! Well my dad is getting it :)

----------

I have torn down the iPad 2 (not crazy enough to do my new iPad) and the home button assembly is actually bonded to the glass with 3M adhesive. The bottom of the button is directly affixed to the screen. If this separates then the button will sit deeper and feel clicky.
You are cazy! But thanks for the info. It does not sit deeper but just has that loose feeling and clicks/creaks when I lightly touch it or run a finger over it. Just surprised to find it this way since we have 2 3GS, 2 4S, one ipad 1, and 2 ipad 2 and have never encountered this issue.
 

Batavian

macrumors 6502
Mar 10, 2011
463
38
I don't even use the home button any more. I'm totally into gestures. In fact the home button is annoying as I'm constantly accidentally hitting it when holding the ipad in landscape.
 

Lukeyy19

macrumors 6502a
Feb 16, 2010
762
1
England, UK
When I rub my finger over mine I can feel it is is slightly raised out of the glass, but the button works perfectly. When you look at the iPad side-on you can just about see its like a hair width higher than the glass, I'm still happy with it though - it's not enough to notice unless you're looking for it. but if you find yours uncomfortable or unsightly then I feel you should have every right to replace it, Apple market themselves as the pinnacle of quality, and as such you expect this quality from them.

Much like I wouldn't buy an Audi and just live with a radio that was protruding form the center console. But if I bought a Diatsu that probably wouldent bother me.
 
Last edited:

BigMcGuire

Contributor
Jan 10, 2012
4,698
5,732
California
Same as the other poster here (Batavian) - I use gestures entirely now. (4 fingers) to go to the home screen.

My home button is recessed - and was on my previous defected iPad 3 as well. I can feel the glass - but the button works perfectly and doesn't bother me at all. It's the same on my iPhone 4s too. In fact, I cut myself a little bit on it. lol.

But the home button works perfect?!
 

bowlerman625

macrumors 68020
Jun 17, 2009
2,135
11
Chicago, IL area
You guys are pathetic.

Swap your iPad because you don't like how the button feels?

Sme people are NEVER happy! Think yourself lucky you have one!
When you spend that kind of money on something, you should be completely satisfied, no matter what this poster thinks!

Make a Genius appt!!
 

Cocolocco

macrumors newbie
Feb 28, 2014
1
0
Philippines
Ipad mini 2 home button

I noticed the deep home button of my ipad mini 2 but it didn't bother me at all... I seldom use the home button for I use the 'assistive touch' feature... They say the home button easily get stucked if constantly used and to avoid pressing it is the only solution... and I covered it so I can't accidentally click it too.
 

Attachments