Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

sam2428

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Mar 8, 2011
404
141
Houston, TX
Hello all, sorry if this has been asked already...I tried to search but could not find what I was looking for.

I know the homepod isnt designed to be a desktop speaker connected to a mac but I was curious how the performance (i.e. audio lag) is now that we are a over a year in with updates and airplay 2.

Can the homepod be used as a sleek and simple desktop speaker replacement or would it still not be a viable option?

I originally passed on the homepod due to price and missing features...but now that prices are dropping I am starting to get intrigued again.
 

Sooby

macrumors member
Apr 5, 2019
61
38
I have two HomePods which I use with my iMac. Having one HomePod is fairly good as a desktop speaker but there are some drawbacks. I don't have many problems with lag when playing Music. There's often a bit of lag when you begin streaming music i.e. it doesn't begin playing right away, but once it starts playing there's no problem. With internet videos it's generally fine; I don't have many problems with watching Youtube, though sometimes it feels that there's just a slight delay with what's happening on screen and the audio, though it's extremely minor and unless I'm looking for it, its not highly noticeable. It sounds very good for Youtube videos as well. The problem with one HomePod however is with watching movies and playing games. I find the sound with movies to be significantly muffled and the bass very boomy -- I can't watch movies with one HomePod. Also when playing games, the sound can be very laggy, taking up to one or two or even more seconds to register what's happening on the screen which is essentially unusable for some games.

Now with two HomePods in stereo, the sound in movies is really good -- it's louder, the voices are clearer and the background sounds also seem better. And there's also no lag. But this leads to the next problem. You can only use stereo HomePods with iTunes when using a Mac. You cannot use stereo HomePods for general use on a Mac e.g. when playing movies on Youtube or streaming a radio station from the internet browser or for playing games. This means that stereo HomePods on a Mac can only be used for movies, tv shows and music if you use iTunes. This doesn't bother me because I watch all my movies from iTunes and I'm an Apple Music subscriber. But it's a significant limitation. So, one HomePod as a desktop speaker is very good for streaming music and quite good for watching general videos on the internet. But if watching movies on your computer or playing games is important to you, then I would be hesitant about purchasing it because it's not very good for those things (though there isn't any lag when watching movies). If you intend on getting two in stereo, then just remember that they're limited to iTunes.
 

steve62388

macrumors 68040
Apr 23, 2013
3,093
1,950
Using the HomePod as a desktop speaker doesn’t really make sense. Why do you need Siri when you’re sitting at your iMac? And then it just becomes a dumb speaker, of which there are better sounding options for the same (or less) money.
 

sam2428

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Mar 8, 2011
404
141
Houston, TX
Using the HomePod as a desktop speaker doesn’t really make sense. Why do you need Siri when you’re sitting at your iMac? And then it just becomes a dumb speaker, of which there are better sounding options for the same (or less) money.

I am upgrading my entire computer setup and my current desktop speakers need major replacement. I also want a smart speaker in my computer room / have been thinking about getting a homepod anyway....so instead of buying new desktop speakers and buying a homepod or other smart speaker my thought process is to have a single homepod on the corner of my desk which can potentially be an elegant solution to both. Less wires overall and a cleaner desk setup. The homepod would still be used as a smart speaker when I am not on the computer and just watching TV or relaxing on the couch, etc.

Sooby, thank you for sharing your experience and for the detailed response! My main use on my computer would be for listening to music and watching Youtube videos, etc. I use Apple music / itunes, but also stream music from other platforms. I do not use my iMac for gaming or watching movies...so I think a single homepod could very well work for what I am trying to achieve. The only time I would need some audio precision would be while doing video editing, but I usually wear headphones when I do this anyway. And I dont video edit very often any more either.
 

Sooby

macrumors member
Apr 5, 2019
61
38
Using the HomePod as a desktop speaker doesn’t really make sense. Why do you need Siri when you’re sitting at your iMac? And then it just becomes a dumb speaker, of which there are better sounding options for the same (or less) money.

In my case, I have the HomePods set up in a multifunction room which I use for work, watching movies, relaxing and for using my treadmill. The HomePods are a versatile and convenient option for streaming music from my iMac/iPhone/iPad when I'm working, relaxing on the lounge chair or working out on the treadmill, and when I want to watch a movie on my TV (my iMac is connected to my TV) I can use them for that as well and they perform very well for movies. If you can get them for a good price, like I did, then they're a good option for performing all these numerous tasks with a high level of convenience.
 

Phil77354

macrumors 68000
Jun 22, 2014
1,922
2,030
Pacific Northwest, U.S.
I've had two HomePod speakers as a stereo pair (since that capability was released) and on my desktop for use with my iMac and iTunes since the HomePod was first released.

After living with various frustrations in how AirPlay was implemented for this particular configuration, with the latest software updates I'm finally getting this to work satisfactorily.

In the past, when I was playing music from my iTunes library, and I selected the HomePod stereo pair for sound output, it would very often only play sound through one of the speakers. I didn't have time to fuss around and try to figure out what might be causing this, and the result was that I was not using these speakers as much as I had intended.

Additionally, when I play from my iTunes library, the play count is now updating properly. That is another thing that wasn't working right previously.

I don't know when these particular fixes were implemented, but today when I decided to try and play music while using my computer, I was very pleasantly surprised to find it all working 'right' for the first time since I purchased the HomePods and began to use them.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sam2428

sam2428

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Mar 8, 2011
404
141
Houston, TX
I've had two HomePod speakers as a stereo pair (since that capability was released) and on my desktop for use with my iMac and iTunes since the HomePod was first released.

After living with various frustrations in how AirPlay was implemented for this particular configuration, with the latest software updates I'm finally getting this to work satisfactorily.

In the past, when I was playing music from my iTunes library, and I selected the HomePod stereo pair for sound output, it would very often only play sound through one of the speakers. I didn't have time to fuss around and try to figure out what might be causing this, and the result was that I was not using these speakers as much as I had intended.

Additionally, when I play from my iTunes library, the play count is now updating properly. That is another thing that wasn't working right previously.

I don't know when these particular fixes were implemented, but today when I decided to try and play music while using my computer, I was very pleasantly surprised to find it all working 'right' for the first time since I purchased the HomePods and began to use them.

Thanks for sharing your experience. In my case I would probably only use a single HomePod, but still promising to hear it’s starting to work better for this use case.

I’ve also been considering just getting standard “dumb” desktop speakers. But that also means more wires to hide, and potentially having to buy a separate subwoofer to get the sound like I want. I just really like how to the HomePod has a deep bass without having a separate unit.
 

xbox40489

macrumors newbie
Aug 9, 2021
1
0
Thanks for sharing your experience. In my case I would probably only use a single HomePod, but still promising to hear it’s starting to work better for this use case.

I’ve also been considering just getting standard “dumb” desktop speakers. But that also means more wires to hide, and potentially having to buy a separate subwoofer to get the sound like I want. I just really like how to the HomePod has a deep bass without having a separate unit.

1x Arcana https://hdfury.com/product/4k-arcana-18gbps/

2x Homepods

2x Apple TV 4K gen 2 (gen 2 Apple TV 4K, have the Audio Return Channel (BETA) feature, to Play Television Audio through the Apple TV to Airplay to the Homepods)

1x HDMI switch with a remote. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07VPD3BXC/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1

1x HDMI biredirectional switch. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08RS2YH8T/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1


Seems to let my Windows 10 Desktop PC, send the Desktop PC sound to the Arcana to be Airplayed to the stereo Homepods. Check the diagram here below. The 2nd Unit of the Apple TV 4K gen 2 below was needed just as a Apple TV 4K gen 2...also using the same stereo homepods. The first unit was used after the Arcana, just to function as the audio stream to be send to the Homepods, for whatever you are plugging into the Arcana's HDMI input.

The HDMI switch with a remote is there to switch in between HDMI input for the Arcana, for example PS4, PC and Xbox 360 etc, etc.

I am still here waiting for the hdmi bi directional switch to come in, so I can confirm if we can go by a setup with only one unit of the Apple TV 4K gen 2. But the suggested hdmi bi directional switch does not have a remote. So it has to be pressed by hand to switch. Which is cumbersome. Until this part also can be automated with a remote.

Ofcourse this setup would work also with only one single Homepod. Not sure about the homepod minis.
 

Attachments

  • 2k21 64GB to 2k21 32GB HomePods_final.png
    2k21 64GB to 2k21 32GB HomePods_final.png
    880.4 KB · Views: 138

dyzfnctional

macrumors 6502
Aug 6, 2008
309
43
is HomePod mini working better with Monterey as desktop speakers for MacBook Pro? Any sync issues like before? Thanks in advance
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.