I am curious which software can you do this in? I have just tried to select nonconsecutive text in Firefox, Pages and TextWrangler and I could not select nonconsecutive text using your method but could in TextEdit. I don't have MS Word anymore but I know I have done it previously with that software. I believe selecting nonconsecutive text is a product of individual software programs rather than Macs in general. Pages used to be able to do it and since they upgraded the program, you no longer can. Upgraded? Hmm. Which program are you using?