Thats the issue. This does not qualify for that. Under Apple's TOS, it requires that the screen to be cracked to use your deductible. So that leads to the insurance fraud discussion.Why is any of this discussion relevant? You have 2 accidental damage claims. Use one to have the screen replaced. Just be mindful of the deductible and if the increased sales price will make sense. Or leave it to the new buyer since the phone is still covered. Just be sure to transfer AC+ as it does not convey to the new owner automatically.