Well, it could be the way I started?
Back in 97 there wasn't much in the way of anything. Winamp was it (I was on a PC at the time), so I had all my music organised in folders;
/Artist/Year - Album/01 - Track Name.mp3
With that system, I can see my entire collection in one glance, from A-Z.
I think another key thing is that I am an album person. I can't just listen to a song. I need to hear the whole album. And then usually the next album, in chronological order.
I've never had a need for Genre, or Ratings and so on, or any of the ID3 tags.
Moving to iTunes was hard. I only really did it for my iPod. I've meticulously edited all my tags to make sure they all play nice in iTunes, but it's still about a million miles away from my folders.
Often, I have an artist's folder organised into Live, Bootlegs, Studio, B Sides and so on. iTunes fails there (except with playlists? I haven't tried yet).
VLC is my default audio player. Oh, how I wish for Winamp
🙂
I never did like the mp3 folder approach, give me a library system any day of the week, i wonder what it is about a person that makes them like one over the other...