Oh, OK
So:
- Connect blank 500GB external
- Use Carbon Copy Cloner/Super Duper, clone internal to blank external
- Insert new 500GB HD into MBP
- Boot up from the External (how?)
- Clone the external onto the internal
Done?
Which program would you/others advise over the 2? I want reliability and simplicity.
No disrespect intended toward
jmann4489's use of the Migration Assistant, but I would seriously suggest you do yourself a favor and go back to the plan you mentioned above for simplicity and the ability to test the validity of your backup etc. Not everything gets transferred using the Migration Assistant in actuality- you can note some of the exceptions in the the Apple document
here regarding Migration Assistant FAQ's. This was written for 10.4 but the exceptions still apply to 10.5 as it was never intended to be a true "cloning" program as you desire.
There are a couple of steps left out of your original process list, so I will copy it and add those steps and you will wind up with an exact duplicate of your current hard drive with no resetting or reinstallation required, ok?
1. Connect blank 500Gb external
-----
1a. Make sure it has been formatted as Mac OS Extended with a GUID
-----Partition map (**) if it is still PC formatted as purchased. If not
-----formatted correctly for Mac use, the cloning programs will not work.
2. Use Carbon Copy Cloner to clone internal to blank external.
-----
2a. When done, test clone by restarting and pressing and holding
-----"Option" after the startup chime until a screen appears that will show
-----all bootable devices attached to your system. Click on the external
-----drive name and press "Enter" to boot from the clone. It will be
-----identical to your internal drive, so play around with it until you are
-----satisfied that is, then shut down the system.
3. Install new 500Gb HD into MBP
-----3a. Boot up from clone again with Option. Use Disk Utility on it to set
-----up the new 500Gb internal drive with Mac OS Extended with GUID
-----partition map (**). (The blank drive will come with a PC format). Quit
-----Disk Utility
4. --eliminate-- you are already booted to the external
5. Run Carbon Copy Cloner and clone external to new internal.
Finally, do a normal restart and system should restart from the internal drive again automatically. If by chance (not likely) it boots again from the external, go into "System Preferences", then into the "Startup Disk" pane, choose your internal drive and click "Restart".
Sit back and enjoy your new larger drive whose contents are identical with the original internal!
(**)
If you need a quickie guide to formatting the drives and assuring that they have the GUID partition map scheme that is essential in this use, just ask!