I tried a few cases recently and ended up keeping the Case Mate Pop. It's an amazing case. No flaking problems at all with mine. Phone is well protected, has nice rubber lip around the screen and is much easier to install or remove the phone compared to the Candyshell. Most importantly for me, it is very comfortable to hold and the side grips are awesome. Most other cases are way to slippery.
I like the case so much that I bought a second one in a different color just for fun. I have a black one and a green one now.