I was going to get the Starlight but a Midnight came up locally for a deal I couldn't pass up. You definitely can see the prints, but the laptop itself is gorgeous, and I don't think it's any worse than other matte finish dark laptops. I'm concerned about cleaning it too often; I don't want something like isopropyl alcohol to slowly wear the surface down to the point it exposes the silver underneath. Not sure if that's possible, but something I'd like to avoid.
I've also noticed that the surface being painted like it is, I don't think I can cover this one in stickers like I do most of my laptops without damaging the finish when removing them. So I may just end up covering it with a plastic snap on cover.