Handbrake takes about 40 mins
I hope you aren't using deinterlace on sources that don't need it... if so you're hurting your encode speed and quality.On my Macbook C2D @ 2ghz with 2gb of ram Handbrake encodes take about two hours on these settings:
Handbrake version 0.9.2 (I heard there were issues with 0.9.3 so I have not bothered to upgrade)
Apple TV preset
Two-pass encoding with turbo first pass
Keep aspect ratio: on
Deinterlace: on
Obviously it all depends on what movie you are ripping. Larger quality sources will take longer and lesser quality sources will go faster.
This setting seems to work the best for me. I hook it up via HDMI to my 42" Panasonic plasma and I could not be happier with the results.
This ongoing process of ripping my library is a big plus in the wife-factor arena as well...she can watch the movies quite easily.
If upgrading to 0.9.3 is worth it and will save me time then I will go ahead and upgrade. It's just that when it was first released I read numerous postings of the application no longer working-period. Maybe that is no longer an issue...I should probably go ahead and just upgrade because your point of deinterlace on/off is obviously something to think about when going through this process.
I hope you aren't using deinterlace on sources that don't need it... if so you're hurting your encode speed and quality.
.9.3 includes the decomb filter which will only deinterlace when it detects it is necessary, but it sounds like you have your own reasons for not wanting to upgrade.
My MacPro averages around 20-30 min per movie right from DVD via Handbrake, using the Universal setting, and subtitles turned on. I have two optical drives, so I can put in two movies and set up them to queue, and come back in about a hour and repeat the process. Movies look great on my ATV.
I need to test pre-rips using MTR to see if it's worth the extra step so I can have the MacPro/Handbrake work all night uninterrupted on a huge queue.
I'd definitely recommend using MTR. It allows you to que up a large amount of files to encode and saves a lot of time. Handbrake isn't really meant to be used as a ripper anyway and support for it is pretty much non-existent (rightfully so). There are also a lot of newer movies out there that have pretty intense copy protections that make a dedicated ripper very valuable.
My 1 ghz iBook G4 takes about 20 hours to Handbrake a film to aTV setting.
wouldn't using MTR mean it's up to the DVD drive speed? I ask b/c when I use the older drive on my mac pro it's longer than when I use the newer drive - maybe 20 mins for the newer drive and 45 for the older one.
Glad to see i'm not alone, my 1.5ghz 12inch powerbook usually takes at least 24 hours for a 2hr film on Atv preset, and boy does is get hot when its doing it
Phil