Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
How to Fix the 'Black Dot' Unicode Bug Crashing iMessage
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The security of no one else being capable of reading your messages. Unlike iMessage, everyone can check Signal's source code for proof.
"cannot be rendered properly", okay, fine, misteaks hapen soemtimes. But "leads to system crashing"? Really? For like the fourth time? No! Go through this code and make it stop making assumptions, and sanity check the inputs. At best it should be displaying an empty black frame to indicate "there's one or more characters here that I can't decode or figure out how to display". But it feels like they're putting additional band-aids on a library to fix specific bugs found, rather than saying, "displaying Unicode is crashing the OS a second time? We need a team to audit the entire library." This is like what Microsoft was doing with Win98 and security, "oh, someone found a way in? let's patch that one way in" (rinse/repeat one thousand times).
It's probably the layout of one or more characters cascading to improper layouts of other things, causing a crash. I don't know why they can't catch this, but I would assume the iOS and Android devs aren't incompetent. Text layout with full accessibility and other support is complicated.
[doublepost=1525883735][/doublepost]
That doesn't fix this problem. It also would not allow me to message anyone I know in real life, lol.
[doublepost=1525883775][/doublepost]
Well that doesn't matter here. It's about getting malicious messages. If anything, privacy guarantees make that harder to enforce.
Last edited:
To my understanding, you are correct about this being caused by thousands of control characters with a width of zero
According to the artice it affects Android as well.
Maybe we shall throw all smartphones out the window?
Sounds good to me!
Hangouts, at least on Android, has never been affected by these frequent iMessage vulnerabilities. You'd think people would stop using iMessage and switch to something else after the first infection or first few infections like with STDs.
Last edited:
You first!According to the artice it affects Android as well.
Maybe we shall throw all smartphones out the window?
It's like no one at Apple or Google has ever met Little Bobby Tables.
How so? iMessage is totally encrypted and tokenized. Add the fact that it's already integrated into every iOS device and auto-sends as SMS when the receiver needs it, I don't see how anything else could possibly be better. Any service that requires me to ask someone to download the app so I can message them isn't worth using IMO.
Yeah, that’s what they tell you. (Facebook tells us the same thing about WhatsApp btw, now would you trust them?) It’s closed sourced so no one knows what’s in the code. Signal on the other hand though is open source and anyone can check exactly how it works.
...and another issue with iOS 11!
This is getting a little ridiculous. We will have another patch coming up in the next couple days probably and then next week most likely iOS 11.4. Obviously they might just combine the patch into iOS 11.4, but still...this is getting crazy.
This is getting a little ridiculous. We will have another patch coming up in the next couple days probably and then next week most likely iOS 11.4. Obviously they might just combine the patch into iOS 11.4, but still...this is getting crazy.
I agree 100%. It would bother me if someone asked me to download an app just to message them, and vice versa! Like you said, iMessage is very secure. End-to-end encryption and tokenized.
I trust Apple when it comes to the security of iMessage.
Until we get iMessage in the cloud, deleting a conversation on one device leaves it intact on the others.
[doublepost=1525888172][/doublepost]
You do realize that iMessage has end-to-end encryption, right?
Alternative facts and sensationalism, as they say.
https://www.androidpolice.com/2013/...oid-app-google-is-aware-and-working-on-a-fix/
(That's even putting aside other messengers and OS's often being affected by those or similar things as well.)
[doublepost=1525888411][/doublepost]
It's crazy how iOS 11 even affects Android....and another issue with iOS 11!
This is getting a little ridiculous. We will have another patch coming up in the next couple days probably and then next week most likely iOS 11.4. Obviously they might just combine the patch into iOS 11.4, but still...this is getting crazy.
Last edited:
iPhone 5 with iOS 6 here...immune to any and all of these issues hahaiPhone 4 with iOS 7 here, immune to this problem.
Oh, give me a break... if we're just going to say "well I don't believe them" then this entire conversation is pointless. Until Apple shows me otherwise, I believe them when they say it's tokenized. They have never given me any reason to assume otherwise, especially when they don't make their money on data mining. Facebook, on the other hand, has given us a LOT of reasons to distrust them and makes all of their money on data mining.
It doesn't affect stock messaging apps or Google messaging apps on Android (I just tried it on my Note 8), only WhatsApp appears to be impacted on Android at this point.According to the artice it affects Android as well.
Maybe we shall throw all smartphones out the window?