Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I think the comment is excluding now defunct Home Brew solutions that handset makers used to make on their own. However, those too probably were based on something else.

Even IOS, Android, Windows Mobile... are all desktop operating systems that have been modified, not TRULY built from scratch. IOS has done the best job. Androids biggest pitfall is that the user is basically running a program on top of Linux. (Yes, I know, it's more technical than that, for for laymens sake I say that).

IOS was almost a Linux based product as well, which most people hear have most likely read that story.

I think this is the best thing for WebOS.
It suffered from 2 problems:
1. Awful hardware (under both HP and Palm(
2. No developer support

This would fix both those issues pretty quickly if other manufactures jump on board, and with Google getting into the hardware business, many companies have been rumored to be looking at alternatives to Android now.

HP even has a win in this. By hanging on to WebOS in part, it positions them to be the gate keeper of an echo system ala Apple or Google, raking in a commission on what's sold and giving a steady revenue stream.

Its the echo system that makes the money, not so much the hardware. Device makers have done well with Android because what they save in in house costs on developing software makes up for the difference and has helped them get more market share.

I'm excited about this. WebOS I always did like... I just hated the hardware and there was nothing for the platform I wanted besides Facebook and few other must haves.

You need to start writing better fiction, and what the heck is an "echo system?"
 
No, I blame HP for the bad marketing. Palm did pretty well when they had WebOS.

The Palm Pre became the fastest selling phone in Sprint's history.

So marketing is pretty important, huh.

I'm a firm believer that marketing only gets you so far... and you gotta have the products to back it up. I don't think the TouchPad was that product.

HP could have put out the coolest TV commercials ever made... but the TouchPad was still the same price as the iPad. Not a very good strategy considering they were a year late to the party... and the iPad was already on their 2nd revision. Oh... and the iPad had apps...

I don't think any amount of HP marketing would have helped the TouchPad.

And about the Palm Pre... "fastest selling" is a rate... not an amount. How many Palm Pres did they actually sell?

The Palm Pre did set some records for Sprint at launch... but that was short-lived. And a few months later Sprint started selling Android phones.

And nobody was talking about the Palm Pre anymore.
 
Windows 8 promises for sometime in the future? MS can barely get WP7 off the ground, never mind that awful Metro UI duct-taped onto another version of Windows (or rather, two versions in one!) Great plan.

$NEXT_VERSION is shaping up to be one heck of a product.

I am so excited about $NEXT_VERSION of Windows. It will go beyond just solving all of the problems with $CURRENT_VERSION, it will be an entirely new paradigm. Forget about security and UI problems, those are all fixed in $NEXT_VERSION. And they’re finally ridding themselves of $ANCIENT_LEGACY_STUFF.

Also, there’ll be $DATABASE_FILESYSTEM. It’ll be awesome!

I wonder how $NEXT_VERSION will compare to $NEXT_NEXT_VERSION.

I love how well you encapsulated Microsoft's Marketing Plan, Ballmer needs to sell this to the current crop of GOP presidential hopefuls with a promise of a 2012 release of the planned $FULL_EMPLOYMENT_PACKAGE, the $TAX_CUT MODULE, and the $CHICKEN IN EVERY POT_SCREENSAVER.

They've gotta love it, it's been spoon fed to MISmanagers for decades along with $HAVE_A_JOB_FOR_LIFE_SONG by promoting the most exploitable OS ever made.
 
So marketing is pretty important, huh.

I'm a firm believer that marketing only gets you so far... and you gotta have the products to back it up. I don't think the TouchPad was that product.

HP could have put out the coolest TV commercials ever made... but the TouchPad was still the same price as the iPad. Not a very good strategy considering they were a year late to the party... and the iPad was already on their 2nd revision. Oh... and the iPad had apps...

And about the Palm Pre... "fastest selling" is a rate... not an amount. How many Palm Pres did they actually sell?

The Palm Pre did set some records for Sprint at launch... but that was short-lived. And a few months later Sprint started selling Android phones.

And nobody was talking about the Palm Pre anymore.

Remember that Droid commercial? The one that everyone predicted would win Moto some crazy mindshare. It turned out to be nothing more than a homophobic slam, after which Apple went on to sell record numbers of iPhones. Fast-forward a couple of years and Moto is buyout-bait. Now they're down to pulling the old RAZR name out of the casket. Truly a Weekend at Bernie's spoof.

Marketing is nice to get a foot in the door. The rest is all about the goods. The strength of the product, and really, of the entire platform.
 
So marketing is pretty important, huh.

I'm a firm believer that marketing only gets you so far... and you gotta have the products to back it up. I don't think the TouchPad was that product.

HP could have put out the coolest TV commercials ever made... but the TouchPad was still the same price as the iPad. Not a very good strategy considering they were a year late to the party... and the iPad was already on their 2nd revision. Oh... and the iPad had apps...

I don't think any amount of HP marketing would have helped the TouchPad.

And about the Palm Pre... "fastest selling" is a rate... not an amount. How many Palm Pres did they actually sell?

The Palm Pre did set some records for Sprint at launch... but that was short-lived. And a few months later Sprint started selling Android phones.

And nobody was talking about the Palm Pre anymore.

The reason iPad sold so well was because of great marketing.

The Palm pre broke a record that was only beat by one phone. The HTC Evo.
 
HP is clueless if they think they can enter a tablet market without also being in the smart phone market, its all about having an ecosystem. When are they going to learn?
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 5_0_1 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/534.46 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.1 Mobile/9A405 Safari/7534.48.3)

RELEASE THE KRAKEN!
 
Windows 8 promises for sometime in the future? MS can barely get WP7 off the ground, never mind that awful Metro UI duct-taped onto another version of Windows (or rather, two versions in one!) Great plan.

$NEXT_VERSION is shaping up to be one heck of a product.

I am so excited about $NEXT_VERSION of Windows. It will go beyond just solving all of the problems with $CURRENT_VERSION, it will be an entirely new paradigm. Forget about security and UI problems, those are all fixed in $NEXT_VERSION. And they’re finally ridding themselves of $ANCIENT_LEGACY_STUFF.

Also, there’ll be $DATABASE_FILESYSTEM. It’ll be awesome!

I wonder how $NEXT_VERSION will compare to $NEXT_NEXT_VERSION.

You're afraid of Microsoft and Windows. It's going to rain on your Apple parade. Windows 7 is already the most successful operating system on earth. Keep spewing your drivel. And keep looking in your rear view mirror, you're about to get passed by a runaway freight train. Hang on tight!!

Remember that Droid commercial? The one that everyone predicted would win Moto some crazy mindshare. It turned out to be nothing more than a homophobic slam, after which Apple went on to sell record numbers of iPhones. Fast-forward a couple of years and Moto is buyout-bait. Now they're down to pulling the old RAZR name out of the casket. Truly a Weekend at Bernie's spoof.

Marketing is nice to get a foot in the door. The rest is all about the goods. The strength of the product, and really, of the entire platform.

Except Android took the market lead from iOS.
 
Windows 8 promises for sometime in the future? MS can barely get WP7 off the ground, never mind that awful Metro UI duct-taped onto another version of Windows (or rather, two versions in one!) Great plan.

$NEXT_VERSION is shaping up to be one heck of a product.

I am so excited about $NEXT_VERSION of Windows. It will go beyond just solving all of the problems with $CURRENT_VERSION, it will be an entirely new paradigm. Forget about security and UI problems, those are all fixed in $NEXT_VERSION. And they’re finally ridding themselves of $ANCIENT_LEGACY_STUFF.

Also, there’ll be $DATABASE_FILESYSTEM. It’ll be awesome!

I wonder how $NEXT_VERSION will compare to $NEXT_NEXT_VERSION.

Windows 7 is a failure? That's a laughable statement.

Microsoft messed up with Vista but 7 is a whole different animal. It's actually better optimised, fast, very stable and has excellent memory management. Get out of your Apple reality distortion field.

Yet, Windows 7 PCs are flying of shelves more than Mac PCs.
 
You're afraid of Microsoft and Windows. It's going to rain on your Apple parade. Windows 7 is already the most successful operating system on earth. Keep spewing your drivel. And keep looking in your rear view mirror, you're about to get passed by a runaway freight train. Hang on tight!!



Except Android took the market lead from iOS.

He doesnt like Windows :eek::eek::eek: Never would have guessed. Windows 8 will take a pee on that parade, MS "gets it" always have. I bet Win8 will be available on disk from day 1 as well ;)

Wonder what will happen one day when they can;t quote "record breaking profits." Guess there is other drivel to use out there.
 
He doesnt like Windows :eek::eek::eek: Never would have guessed. Windows 8 will take a pee on that parade, MS "gets it" always have. I bet Win8 will be available on disk from day 1 as well ;)

Wonder what will happen one day when they can;t quote "record breaking profits." Guess there is other drivel to use out there.

When they can't quote record profits, they will say that profits aren't important. They will change the rules as they always do, ie, sales are irrelevant unless they make Apple look good, etc, etc. They will that Windows 8 is vaporware, but they kept saying, look out Android, iOS 5 is coming. When Apple steals Moto tech, it's just old tech and doesn't matter. If someone does it to Apple, Apple sues to protect their IP. You get the idea. A most hypocritical bunch, that's for sure.
 
When they can't quote record profits, they will say that profits aren't important. They will change the rules as they always do, ie, sales are irrelevant unless they make Apple look good, etc, etc. They will that Windows 8 is vaporware, but they kept saying, look out Android, iOS 5 is coming. When Apple steals Moto tech, it's just old tech and doesn't matter. If someone does it to Apple, Apple sues to protect their IP. You get the idea. A most hypocritical bunch, that's for sure.

God love em.

:apple:
 
The whole "blah stole from blah", or "bleh is a copycat" argument is SO old these days. Hell, it was old practically the first time someone started muttering on about it.

See, people. Nothing exists in a vacuum. Every company out there takes good ideas from elsewhere, and implements them alongside their own good ideas. Apple does it. MS does it. Google does it. In the end, it means better products for us all. So why the hell do some of you even care who copied who?

Imagine if you were to take this attitude and extend it to other fields of interest. Like what if physics majors argued about who copied who.

"I don't know why Einstein is so well liked these days. All he did was copy ideas Newton came up with centuries ago. But hey. Not everyone can be clever and innovative OLOL. I hope his family sues the everliving crap out Einstein :apple:".

It's dumb. Shut up about copying. Just because you heard about some clever idea first from an Apple product doesn't mean it didn't exist elsewhere beforehand.
 
This is great news. WebOS is awesome--and I'm glad it may live on on other devices. I always felt it wasn't fully optimized on the Touchpad--so hopefully another tablet maker will give it a try with some better hardware. Though, it might be wise to try and go the Blackberry route at first and emulate some Android apps.

Ditto. I'm really happy about this too. I never felt it's potential was fully realized on any device it shipped with. I'm looking forward to see what it's future holds.
 
The reason iPad sold so well was because of great marketing.

The Palm pre broke a record that was only beat by one phone. The HTC Evo.

Like I said before, and others have said too... marketing is only part of the puzzle. The product itself is a bigger reason it does well. And... the presence of other products on the market is something else they have to deal with.

Even if HP had the most amazing mind-blowing commercials... it was still competing against the iPad... a product that has been around for over a year.

What could HP have possibly said to make someone choose a TouchPad instead of the iPad... for the same price? What kind of marketing would that take?


I already said the Palm Pre was a record-setting phone... it sold 50,000 on its first day and 100,000 the first week.

While that was a great launch for Sprint... it's laughable compared to other phones and carriers.

And look what happened... Palm nearly went out of business... forcing themselves to be an acquisition target.

Do you still stick to your earlier comment? "Palm did pretty well when they had WebOS"
 
What is HP smoking?

They're out of their minds. How exactly is HP going to make any money on this?
 
Like I said before, and others have said too... marketing is only part of the puzzle. The product itself is a bigger reason it does well. And... the presence of other products on the market is something else they have to deal with.

Even if HP had the most amazing mind-blowing commercials... it was still competing against the iPad... a product that has been around for over a year.

What could HP have possibly said to make someone choose a TouchPad instead of the iPad... for the same price? What kind of marketing would that take?


I already said the Palm Pre was a record-setting phone... it sold 50,000 on its first day and 100,000 the first week.

While that was a great launch for Sprint... it's laughable compared to other phones and carriers.

And look what happened... Palm nearly went out of business... forcing themselves to be an acquisition target.

Do you still stick to your earlier comment? "Palm did pretty well when they had WebOS"

Palm never nearly went out of business. HP Touchpad is a great tablet. Marketing is what you need to sell anything. You can have the best product out there but you won't be able to sell it well without marketing.
 
Last edited:
This is great news. WebOS is awesome--and I'm glad it may live on on other devices. I always felt it wasn't fully optimized on the Touchpad--so hopefully another tablet maker will give it a try with some better hardware. Though, it might be wise to try and go the Blackberry route at first and emulate some Android apps.

As an iOS [and Mac] developer and user, I must say webOS has a way better e.mail client and AppStore client than iOS 5. I own a couple TouchPads, and they beat the socks off any android tablet that I've tried. HP should have led the field in competing with Apple, as their product was the best alternative out there [i've found the TP to be more like the 1st gen iPad and that's not a bad thing considering how far a head start Apple had].

With webOS living on, and future hardware running it coming from HP, this can only be bad news for Google and good news for consumers. webOS is a really solid platform and hopefully this will inspire Apple to improve some of their apps [kinda like how Notification Center was inspired by Android].

This was a very smart move of HP's to do this. I think this worries Apple more than Android does, since Android truly is crap. iOS and webOS will be pushing each other innovation-wise and that's a cool thing!
 
This was a very smart move of HP's to do this. I think this worries Apple more than Android does, since Android truly is crap. iOS and webOS will be pushing each other innovation-wise and that's a cool thing!

Android isn't crap. It's a great OS, So is iOS, Windows Phone, and WebOS. They're all great.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.