I found that my AT&T bill was less with the standalone data plans.
Current Plan w/ 5 iPhones
My monthly bill with taxes for 5 iPhones, each with a 2GB Data plan, is about $210 on AT&T with a 15% fan discount. The discount doesn't apply to the $9.99 add-a-phone cost, but it applies to all data plans of $25 or more.
FamilyTalk Nation 700Min with Rollover ($51)
1st iPhone5 with 2GB Data ($21.25)
2nd iPhone5 with 2GB Data ($9.99 + $21.25)
3rd iPhone5 with 2GB Data ($9.99 + $21.25)
4th iPhone5 with 2GB Data ($9.99 + $21.25)
5th iPhone5 with 2GB Data ($9.99 + $21.25)
(Optional: Unlimited messaging and m2m calling on all phones for $30 extra.)
Shared Plan w/ 5 iPhones
10GB Shared Plan ($102)
1st iPhone5 ($30)
2nd iPhone5 ($30)
3rd iPhone5 ($30)
4th iPhone5 ($30)
5th iPhone5 ($30)
The total for the shared plan is near $270 with taxes, or $50+ more per month.
I just did a price comparison at AT&T (although I have Verizon).
If data is more important to you, you can get 2 individual plans for $149 a month before discounts.
This includes 3GB data each (6GB total/not shared), 450 min/mon, rollover, 5000 nights and weekends, unlimited family messaging. With roller this would be plenty sufficient for users who just want more data.
For the 4GB shared plan, you would pay 150 dollars, however if minutes are more important than data, this would be the better deal as you get unlimited minutes and texts. However, with only two people and rollerover, to me the 6GB (3+3) seems like the better deal.
Does Verizon even offer individual plans anymore? I was looking on their site and couldn't find them.
I really wouldn't mind switching to AT&T so I could tell Verizon I don't want to "share everything", but I consistently get the best signal with them in the majority of the areas I'm in during the work day. AT&T signal isn't bad by any means, but where the people I work with that have AT&T have one or two bars, I will be a full 5 bars.
It just seems kind of dumb that when you are sharing the same pool of data, you pay 40 dollars per additional line (same as before with unlimited data 9.99 + 30.00). It would be a bit more appealing if the old plans were offered, but by going with a share everything plan you could get unlimited minutes, 2GB shared data, and then add additional smartphones for 20 bucks a pop or something.
I am still debating on what to do. I almost pulled the trigger on upgrading and switching to Verizon Share Everything 4GB plan as it would be about the same price as I am paying now except I would lose unlimited data, but I just couldn't stand paying an "Activation fee" that i used to not have to pay in order to "upgrade" to a plan that I do not even want. And they would not waive this fee, which is why I wouldn't mind
waving goodbye to them.