Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

RUGGLES99

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Feb 9, 2015
409
99
Ever since I got a Microsoft Surface Pro 4 and the 11" Surface 3 I hardly use my MBP and my 1st generation base, gold RMB. The Surfaces are just so much more flexible as 2-in-1s with touch screens, etc. It's clear apple has fallen so far behind if you give the surface/surface books a try. and so less expensive than macs.
 
Well, I also think that Apple has fallen behind. But not because lack of touchscreen and 2in1 devices. I hate that my keyboard is stuck, I hate adapters and dongles, and I really hate 'make it thinner' culture that prevails in Apple.

I have tried Surface Book, and I simply didn't find it suiting me at all. And no, windows has got nothing to do with it, since I use windows 10 all the time.

But ok, I really don't like tablets at all. It doesn't matter if they are iOS, Android or Windows. In my line of work, I found no use for them. Except media consumption. But even there I find macbook 12 to be a better option.

Maybe if I were a graphic artists or something similar, then I wound find SB to be excellent or better then MBP. But I don't deal with photos or drawing :)
 
It's really a question of personal needs, and that's what it comes down to. I still use my 2012 model for typing. I've used it for audio production and mixing when a dual core was still sufficient, which it still can be for light usage, but yea,

I wish MBPs would have followed trend, improved on cooling efficiency instead of making it thinner so we could actually maximize our processors, at least those of us that have that need.
 
As I stated I got the SP4 not the SB. I wanted something far slimmer and lighter and didn't need the extreme power of the SB. Microsoft is about to bring out the SP5, and I'm hoping for a Surface 4 to replace the Surface 3, which is so far superior to any Ipad I have ever owned.



Well, I also think that Apple has fallen behind. But not because lack of touchscreen and 2in1 devices. I hate that my keyboard is stuck, I hate adapters and dongles, and I really hate 'make it thinner' culture that prevails in Apple.

I have tried Surface Book, and I simply didn't find it suiting me at all. And no, windows has got nothing to do with it, since I use windows 10 all the time.

But ok, I really don't like tablets at all. It doesn't matter if they are iOS, Android or Windows. In my line of work, I found no use for them. Except media consumption. But even there I find macbook 12 to be a better option.

Maybe if I were a graphic artists or something similar, then I wound find SB to be excellent or better then MBP. But I don't deal with photos or drawing :)
 
I used a Surface Pro 4 for work and hated it
Just traded it in for a Dell laptop about 2 weeks ago
Sorry I didn't do it sooner

It all depends on what you are trying to accomplish, your personal preferences, workflow, etc.
For my purposes, the Dell laptop is far and away superior to the SP4

Or course I prefer my MBP at home and my MBA I keep at work
But I need my work issued laptop for many things, and the SP4 just didn't fit my needs

Clearly no device is perfect for everyone
 
I used a SP and SB, and to be honest, I prefer the Surface Book over the Surface Pro
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
I have a SP4 and a late 2013 15" rMBP. Both have their uses. the rMBP is much more powerful with a quad core processor, dGPU, and 16 gb of ram. The keyboard and trackpad is also better. So for content creation and gaming, it's what I use. For the SP4, it's amazing for content consumption on the go. Basically a tablet with a core i5 processor, so very fast, for what it is, with a nice screen.
 
I'm not sure whether or not to take this thread seriously.

I agree, the clickbait title is very off-putting.

Nevertheless, I'll bite. I've actually been considering either the SP4 or SB for a month or so now. I've been in the Apple ecosystem for six years and had my current MBP for five of those. I'm not in dire need of a replacement, but I may want an upgrade soon.

Maybe if I were a graphic artists or something similar, then I wound find SB to be excellent or better then MBP.

I actually am a graphic designer, which is much of the reason why Surface seems so appealing. They seem to be cornering that market more than Apple at the moment. I know macOS is the industry standard (or so I'm lead to believe, I'm not sure if that's still the case) but at the same time it feels silly to spend an extra $1000 premium on every machine I buy just for the OS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: m4v3r1ck
SP4 not enough battery runtime for my needs, and I am more notebook orientated, equally my Retina Mac's are fast becoming little more than media centres having replaced Apple as the provider of my 13" notebook solution with Microsoft's Surface Book.

In many respects Surface Book is the notebook I once envisaged only Apple would be capable of producing, had some suggested 5 years ago I would opt for Windows, let alone a Microsoft product I would have just laughed. Spin forward; SurfaceBook is without any doubts the best notebook I have used or owned, with my sights firmly on Surface Book 2.

Apple still produces very nice hardware, equally have given up on Apple as a provider for my professional solutions; being not current, not practical and not representing the value Mac's once did. To me Apple today seems intent on milking the PC space as much as possible while the going is good, like others I am voting with my wallet, both personally & professionally...

Q-6
 
  • Like
Reactions: m4v3r1ck
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.