Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Big Ben

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 28, 2010
22
0
I got my Kinetic Case tonight.
Quick summery… I am stoked!!!

If you want the long winded version read on… Sorry about the horrible pics.
My first impression of this piece is that it as nicely made as anything I have ever seen. The tiny little bevels that are machined into the part really show the attention to detail. I own a few really nice bicycles and I am used to being disappointed by the quality of parts because I compare everything to my super expensive bicycles. But this case would hold its own next to ANY of my over priced bike parts. The BEST part is that this thing feels awesome to hold!

I was most curious about how the case affects the signal because I owned an Element Case and ended selling it on ebay because I could not get it to work, even after wrapping my phone in electrical tape. And, I could not get a response from Element about returning the case.

I try to take people for their word, but I have to say that with my experience with the Element and all the talk about the other brands I have been a bit nervous about the Kinetic Case. But, after Tim gave me his explanation and ended up saying that if I did not like it that he would be happy to take it back I jumped in.

Here is what came with my case…
Case: Two parts that look like a J
Screen Protectors: Front and back. I have not put them on yet because I have the invisa shields on now. The screen protectors also came with a nice little cloth to clean everything with.
Back plates: A clear plastic piece and a really nice carbon fiber piece. This is actually a real hard plate of carbon fiber. I am not even sure if the sticker that came with my element case was real carbon fiber. After I ordered my case with the carbon back plate I noticed something on the Q&A section of their website that says something about some of their testers had some signal loss when using the carbon fiber back plate I was a little worried about my ordering the CF plate. I emailed them about it and they said they only had a few testers report a little loss when away from a strong signal. Well, I am “away from a strong signal”.

I mounted everything up minus their screen protectors and it went together really nice. I tried both back plates and I like how the clear shows off the apple logo, but I am a sucker for Carbon Fiber so that is probably what I will run if I don’t see any signal issues with it. All of the signal testing I did tonight was with the CF plate.
The first thing I did was look at t
he signal. I live in a kinda crappy AT&T area and get 1-3 bars in my house. I never really loose signal, but I can never really brag about it either. I can sit my phone in the same spot for ten minutes and watch the bars go from 1 to 3 and back to 1 a few times. So, with my new case it pretty much does the same thing. I will do a signal test with the numbers, but I need to google that to remember how to do it. I went into the closet in the back of my house with the case off and I get a pretty solid 1 bar and the GPS shows that I am on my patio which is about ten feet away. When I put the case on I am still getting 1 bar and the GPS shows that I am in my bathroom which is about 10-15 feet the other direction.

The other good news is that my car charger fits easily, and my wife’s cheap radio shack accessory jack easily fits into the head phone hole so I can listen to my iPhone in my truck.

I stayed up too late doing this. So, I will report back when I have some more time with this case.

The bad news… I am a big Dumb A$$. I dropped the phone from my high bar onto the tile floor. My two year old was in my arms and tried to crab it. When trying to catch it I actually slapped it into the ground harder which did not help. The good news is that my phone survived, the bad news is that I got two dings in the case. You can see the scratches in the case in one of the pics. Man this pisses me off. It wouldn’t be a big deal if it happen a month from now, but the first hour I had the thing???


Crash.jpg

Headphone.jpg

Griffinplug.jpg

Signal.jpg

Signalnocase.jpg
 
Nice Case, Slight Imperfections are to be expected with these aluminum and custom cases. Nothing to get down on, I considered the Kinetic but its to round and bubbly for my liking. Congrats on the new purchase and great to see another case which does not affect cellular signal reliability.
 
It is not too bad looking. It may work for you, but aluminum is aluminum, and it will affect signal and gps just like the Vapor did.
Each new case manufacturer comes out and says that their phone is designed to not hurt signal, and we all know that is pure bunk!
I too had a Vapor, and agree that it is awesome looking, but I too sold it on EBay because it sometimes caused me to lose service and receive texts. It worked most of the time, but with 4 iPhones in my home, I need to be sure I can reach my family members when I called them.

Now we are all sporting the 4 dollar bumpers from sw box. Exactly like apple bumpers, but a whole lot less money.

I am waiting for Element Case to come out with a case made out of a resin or plastic, that looks like the Vapor. When that happens, I'll buy it.
 
Thanks for the review. I got an email that mine shipped and I can't wait to get it. Glad to hear that it saved your phone. I'll post something up after I get mine.

I like the look of it more than the square element style cases. That's one thing that I don't like about the new iPhone is the squared sides.

Thanks again Ben, I hope to have mine by the weekend and hopefully I don't drop mine so quickly, :-D
 
It is not too bad looking. It may work for you, but aluminum is aluminum, and it will affect signal and gps just like the Vapor did.
Each new case manufacturer comes out and says that their phone is designed to not hurt signal, and we all know that is pure bunk!
QUOTE]

It doesn't seem like "bunk" to me.

Just a quick update. Today will be the 2nd day using the Kinetic Case with no problems yet. I see between one and five bars depending on where I am at in Northern California. I drove over to the coast yesterday and I did loose all signal for few minutes but so did my buddies 3G phone. AT&T is really spotty in the out laying areas in Northern California, and this is the only time my phone went to searching.
As far as I can tell the CF back plate might hurt my reception by one bar, but has yet to make my phone go to searching when I would normally be at one bar. But, Kinetic Case does state that this is a possibility on their website.
Does anyone have a link or key word for me to google search the numbers signal test?
 
no offense but that case makes it look a bit like the 3GS :D

No offense taken.
Obviously I am not happy that you don’t like the looks. But I also realize that one case will not make everyone happy. One of our top priorities was to make the case comfortable to hold and use. All of our testers preferred the more rounded case, so that is what we decided to make. Maybe someday we will make a case with harder lines to make everyone happy.
 
It is not too bad looking. It may work for you, but aluminum is aluminum, and it will affect signal and gps just like the Vapor did.
Each new case manufacturer comes out and says that their phone is designed to not hurt signal, and we all know that is pure bunk!
QUOTE]

It doesn't seem like "bunk" to me.

Just a quick update. Today will be the 2nd day using the Kinetic Case with no problems yet. I see between one and five bars depending on where I am at in Northern California. I drove over to the coast yesterday and I did loose all signal for few minutes but so did my buddies 3G phone. AT&T is really spotty in the out laying areas in Northern California, and this is the only time my phone went to searching.
As far as I can tell the CF back plate might hurt my reception by one bar, but has yet to make my phone go to searching when I would normally be at one bar. But, Kinetic Case does state that this is a possibility on their website.
Does anyone have a link or key word for me to google search the numbers signal test?

I am assuming by you saying the numbers test you mean field test? If so you go to the phone's key pad and dial *3001#12345#* the press call and it should go from bars to db's. That is FAR more accurate then just bars showing.
 
No offense taken.
Obviously I am not happy that you don’t like the looks. But I also realize that one case will not make everyone happy. One of our top priorities was to make the case comfortable to hold and use. All of our testers preferred the more rounded case, so that is what we decided to make. Maybe someday we will make a case with harder lines to make everyone happy.

If you can make a case with zero signal problem with similar lines of the Vapor case then I'm in.... along with a huge number of Vapor case lovers out there :) $$$
 
I got my Kinetic Case tonight.
Quick summery… I am stoked!!!

If you want the long winded version read on… Sorry about the horrible pics.
My first impression of this piece is that it as nicely made as anything I have ever seen. The tiny little bevels that are machined into the part really show the attention to detail. I own a few really nice bicycles and I am used to being disappointed by the quality of parts because I compare everything to my super expensive bicycles. But this case would hold its own next to ANY of my over priced bike parts. The BEST part is that this thing feels awesome to hold!

I was most curious about how the case affects the signal because I owned an Element Case and ended selling it on ebay because I could not get it to work, even after wrapping my phone in electrical tape. And, I could not get a response from Element about returning the case.

I try to take people for their word, but I have to say that with my experience with the Element and all the talk about the other brands I have been a bit nervous about the Kinetic Case. But, after Tim gave me his explanation and ended up saying that if I did not like it that he would be happy to take it back I jumped in.

Here is what came with my case…
Case: Two parts that look like a J
Screen Protectors: Front and back. I have not put them on yet because I have the invisa shields on now. The screen protectors also came with a nice little cloth to clean everything with.
Back plates: A clear plastic piece and a really nice carbon fiber piece. This is actually a real hard plate of carbon fiber. I am not even sure if the sticker that came with my element case was real carbon fiber. After I ordered my case with the carbon back plate I noticed something on the Q&A section of their website that says something about some of their testers had some signal loss when using the carbon fiber back plate I was a little worried about my ordering the CF plate. I emailed them about it and they said they only had a few testers report a little loss when away from a strong signal. Well, I am “away from a strong signal”.

I mounted everything up minus their screen protectors and it went together really nice. I tried both back plates and I like how the clear shows off the apple logo, but I am a sucker for Carbon Fiber so that is probably what I will run if I don’t see any signal issues with it. All of the signal testing I did tonight was with the CF plate.
The first thing I did was look at t
he signal. I live in a kinda crappy AT&T area and get 1-3 bars in my house. I never really loose signal, but I can never really brag about it either. I can sit my phone in the same spot for ten minutes and watch the bars go from 1 to 3 and back to 1 a few times. So, with my new case it pretty much does the same thing. I will do a signal test with the numbers, but I need to google that to remember how to do it. I went into the closet in the back of my house with the case off and I get a pretty solid 1 bar and the GPS shows that I am on my patio which is about ten feet away. When I put the case on I am still getting 1 bar and the GPS shows that I am in my bathroom which is about 10-15 feet the other direction.

The other good news is that my car charger fits easily, and my wife’s cheap radio shack accessory jack easily fits into the head phone hole so I can listen to my iPhone in my truck.

I stayed up too late doing this. So, I will report back when I have some more time with this case.

The bad news… I am a big Dumb A$$. I dropped the phone from my high bar onto the tile floor. My two year old was in my arms and tried to crab it. When trying to catch it I actually slapped it into the ground harder which did not help. The good news is that my phone survived, the bad news is that I got two dings in the case. You can see the scratches in the case in one of the pics. Man this pisses me off. It wouldn’t be a big deal if it happen a month from now, but the first hour I had the thing???


Crash.jpg

Headphone.jpg

Griffinplug.jpg

Signal.jpg

Signalnocase.jpg
Thanks for the post. Looks awesome in the red. :)
 
I am assuming by you saying the numbers test you mean field test? If so you go to the phone's key pad and dial *3001#12345#* the press call and it should go from bars to db's. That is FAR more accurate then just bars showing.


Thanks for the heads up on the field testing. I've been playing with this a lot for a couple days now.

I read on another posting that people are looking for reviews of the Kinetic Case from people that have been around here for awhile. I understand where you guys are coming form so I will let this thread die. But, for whatever it is worth. I’m happy with this case. As fat as my pictures might make it look, it really doesn’t seem fat to me and it feels really nice.

But, another question about the field test. I have only been testing it with the case on while I am on the road or at the office. I have been playing with the field test at home by taking the case on and off. The numbers sure bounce around a lot with the case on or off. At the office I can leave my phone in the same spot and it will bounce between mid 70s to low 100s over ten minutes.

At home with the case on and off it is hard to know exactly what the case is doing because it will be between the low 90s to as high as 110. I have seen it go up to 110 with and without the case on. It never stays at 110 very long with or without the case but I have tried to hurry up and make a quick phone call and it makes calls just find at 110, but it is usually higher when I get off the phone.

Another question…
When does it go to 1 bar? It seems like I have seen it at 103 with both 1 bar and 2 bars. Does anyone have a breakdown for numbers to bars? 104+ is one bar, 90-96 is three bars etc.???
Does anyone have an opinion of what number calls start going crappy?
 
Color

Before I order: Is the red a deep red or just red. From the pics it looks like a deep red. High gloss or semi gloss finish? Thanks.
 
I read on another posting that people are looking for reviews of the Kinetic Case from people that have been around here for awhile. I understand where you guys are coming form so I will let this thread die. But, for whatever it is worth. I’m happy with this case. As fat as my pictures might make it look, it really doesn’t seem fat to me and it feels really nice.

No need to let this thread die. You wrote a good review and included some good quailty pics. Good job.
 
Before I order: Is the red a deep red or just red. From the pics it looks like a deep red. High gloss or semi gloss finish? Thanks.

The red is a pretty rich, bright red. It's not a very deep red but more vibrant. They have a glossy finish from the teflon coating.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_2_1 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Mobile/8C148)

Austin M. said:
Mine just arrived. will post some pics and first impressions soon! I got it in the red.

Did you order or request it? I like metal cases but font know if I would buy this one
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_2_1 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Mobile/8C148)



Did you order or request it? I like metal cases but font know if I would buy this one

Requested, but he said they are very busy and out of stock now, they only had a red one left.
 
Bad signal

I have tried several aluminum cases. All caused my signal bars to drop to barely '1'. Tried electrical tape, tried coating frame with rubber cement, tried gasket maker from a auto supply store. Nothing works. So why should this? What makes this different from any other aluminum case? I ordered a case from Atomic, hybrid. Coming Mon. . Not as pretty as the Kinetic. Will let you all know how it works.
 
Here are my first impressions so far. As for a quick summary, I really like it. Here are some of the pros and cons of the case, pictures coming soon!

Pros:
Feels very comfortable in the hand
Bright and shiny
Comes with a back plate (carbon fibre or acrylic) and includes two screen protectors, a cloth, a hex wrench, and six hex wrench screws, a lot of goodies
Simple and not overkill

Cons
A little bit on the bulkier side as far as bumpers go.
Degrades signal about 1-2 bars. :(
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.