And it all worked out in the end. I was able to get to the Genius Bar for an appointment at 4:20 this afternoon and I was treated awesome. I was upfront about what happened (I dropped it from about 2 feet) and they took it to the back, put a new screen on it and thanked me for my honesty. Said it was the reason that they were going to replace my screen free of charge. I ended up buying a better case on their recommendation for $30 but even with that I saved $170.