i5 11inch vs 2GB vs 4GB

adamtj11

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Feb 26, 2011
408
17
Belfast
im in the process of trying to sell my Macbook Pro 2010 right now so I can get a Macbook Air 2011, probably the bass 11 inch version. Just wondering is it worth the extra 70 odd to get the 4gb of ram compared to 2gb? Im coming from a machine with 4gb and I'm worried 2gb would be crippling for me.
 

Starfyre

macrumors 68030
Nov 7, 2010
2,766
990
im in the process of trying to sell my Macbook Pro 2010 right now so I can get a Macbook Air 2011, probably the bass 11 inch version. Just wondering is it worth the extra 70 odd to get the 4gb of ram compared to 2gb? Im coming from a machine with 4gb and I'm worried 2gb would be crippling for me.
Comparing processor vs ram upgrade.. the 4GB is the one that will make the most noticable difference.
 
Comment

adamtj11

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Feb 26, 2011
408
17
Belfast
As usual with these kinds of questions there is no helpful information that would allow anyone to answer it.
Im a developer. I would be running iTunes, Xcode, Safari, occasionally iLife stuff and maybe the odd game, Sometimes different combinations at the same time, other times just individually.
 
Comment

adamtj11

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Feb 26, 2011
408
17
Belfast
Comparing processor vs ram upgrade.. the 4GB is the one that will make the most noticable difference.
Thanks for the reply, just have to get it right first time around here , with the RAM soldered on the logic board.
 
Comment

rds

macrumors regular
Aug 9, 2007
148
0
Im a developer. I would be running iTunes, Xcode, Safari, occasionally iLife stuff and maybe the odd game, Sometimes different combinations at the same time, other times just individually.
Without question, you need 4GB. Speaking from experience, 2GB starts to drag with a few apps open and is really frustrating. No doubt running Lion will add some weight to this argument.

i5 vs i7? Who cares. Unless you encode a lot and seconds matter to you, CPU specs are pretty irrelevant these days.
 
Comment

Brenzo

macrumors regular
May 1, 2011
121
13
Chicago
i5 vs i7? Who cares. Unless you encode a lot and seconds matter to you, CPU specs are pretty irrelevant these days.
I just took your advice and cancelled my order to downgrade to i5 and save $150. Will put that money towards upgrading processor in new Mini that will serve as my workhorse now. Thanks.
 
Comment

WardC

macrumors 68030
Oct 17, 2007
2,727
213
Fort Worth, TX
I am actually surprised Apple didn't nix the 2GB entry-level and start with all models having 4GB of RAM with the new 2011 MBAs, I was expecting 4GB on the base models and an 8GB BTO option (but that is not available, we know). I feel that going forward, you will be much better off with 4GB, and that future versions of OS X such as 10.8 may require a minimum of 4GB of RAM. I am not even sure how well Lion runs on 2GB of RAM just yet.
 
Comment

adamtj11

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Feb 26, 2011
408
17
Belfast
Okay so im struggling to afford the higher model , so the stock option seems to be the only option with the 2gb of ram. After trying my sisters Macbook Air it seemed to fulfill my needs with 2gb for web browsing, iTunes and Xcode. I have a Mac Mini with 4gb of Ram so if worse comes to the worst I can resort to that to take the weight off the air with memory intense apps, the most gaming i ever do is the odd dip into a Football manager game or WOW the odd time .
 
Comment

unixphone

macrumors regular
Sep 25, 2008
133
4
i got 4GB ram and i5 for my 11"

make sure to use discover 5% cashback, education discount and sell the $100 gift card & printer online.
 
Comment

adamtj11

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Feb 26, 2011
408
17
Belfast
i got 4GB ram and i5 for my 11"

make sure to use discover 5% cashback, education discount and sell the $100 gift card & printer online.
Huh? I understand the education discount but what about the printer and 5% cashback?
 
Comment

theRick119

macrumors member
Apr 27, 2008
83
1
If you were not already consisting it, I'd recommend buying online. Perhaps the $50 price drop and "deferred" ;) sales tax might make the upgrade a more viable option for you.

I had the '10 with 2gb of ram and a 64gb SSD and I sold it for the 4 with 128.

I have similar usage and rarely found myself using virtual memory, but even when I did, the SSD helped. But I found the HD to be very limiting and I found myself thinking about everything I wanted to install based on Mbs instead of need.

I don't know what kind of developer you are, but I also need VMs and the ram limitations do show up with VMs running and kill your HD space.

Everyone is different, but I don't think 2 and 64 are sufficient for a heavy user.

(edit: sorry missed the Ireland part, I have no idea if buying online and sales tax considerations will help you in any way)
 
Comment

adamtj11

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Feb 26, 2011
408
17
Belfast
If you were not already consisting it, I'd recommend buying online. Perhaps the $50 price drop and "deferred" ;) sales tax might make the upgrade a more viable option for you.

I had the '10 with 2gb of ram and a 64gb SSD and I sold it for the 4 with 128.

I have similar usage and rarely found myself using virtual memory, but even when I did, the SSD helped. But I found the HD to be very limiting and I found myself thinking about everything I wanted to install based on Mbs instead of need.

I don't know what kind of developer you are, but I also need VMs and the ram limitations do show up with VMs running and kill your HD space.

Everyone is different, but I don't think 2 and 64 are sufficient for a heavy user.

(edit: sorry missed the Ireland part, I have no idea if buying online and sales tax considerations will help you in any way)
Well I'm a iOS and Mac developer, nothing serious just something i do in my spare time, I've tried the 2011 stock base model there, seems to do what i want it to do. No need for VM's I never would need to run both simultaneously Windows and OS X. So ill have bootcamp which will run fine i assume on 2gb of ram. The size of the SSD doesn't matter much to me as I won't really be storing much on it in terms of Photos and video(I have a Mac Mini loaded with Ram and HD space for that). Well buying online is about €50 cheaper and ships in 24hrs so no problem there!
 
Comment

teerexx52

macrumors 68000
May 1, 2005
1,974
98
Florida West Coast
I have the base model but I am using it for surfing, email, iPhoto. I have a MacBook pro for heavy usage. Just wanted something very light to take out to Starbucks and such. No problems with it at all. Plenty fast.
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.