Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

WabbalaFlumpkin

macrumors member
Original poster
Feb 26, 2018
43
10
Las Vegas
I have been repairing an IBM Thinkpad R52, I got it working for awhile, however recently the computer has failed to boot properly, it says that it cannot detect the HDD, this happened suddenly and without any signs of failure. I have not opened the machine since it was last working, what could be the potential issues with this machine?
 
Mobo failure or possibly the HD power/data connector. I would also try a new drive. I actual have one of these that is still working fine on it's original drive.
 
Mobo failure or possibly the HD power/data connector. I would also try a new drive. I actual have one of these that is still working fine on it's original drive.
All original parts, except for the HDD which I upgraded. The computer would beep and give me a screen showwing that the HDD wasn't correctly formatted for the machine, it still worked though. I tried installing Puppy Linux and the machine couldn't detect a HDD.
 
All original parts, except for the HDD which I upgraded. The computer would beep and give me a screen showwing that the HDD wasn't correctly formatted for the machine, it still worked though. I tried installing Puppy Linux and the machine couldn't detect a HDD.
I would try a fresh lubuntu install on it. May just be a driver issue with puppy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sracer
I would try a fresh lubuntu install on it. May just be a driver issue with puppy.
I agree. Puppy Linux specializes in minimalism. I'd recommend something like Linux Mint or Lubuntu. They're designed to be more general purpose distros and have wider driver support. I use Linux Mint Mate on my "newer" vintage ThinkPads (like the X131e) and Lubuntu has been terrific on my T42 (which is older than the R52).
 
I agree. Puppy Linux specializes in minimalism. I'd recommend something like Linux Mint or Lubuntu. They're designed to be more general purpose distros and have wider driver support. I use Linux Mint Mate on my "newer" vintage ThinkPads (like the X131e) and Lubuntu has been terrific on my T42 (which is older than the R52).
I only tried Linux because the computer didn't boot at all, it said it couldnt find an OS! It used to have Windows XP and it worked great! I'm starting to suspect HDD failure.
 
I have been repairing an IBM Thinkpad R52, I got it working for awhile, however recently the computer has failed to boot properly, it says that it cannot detect the HDD, this happened suddenly and without any signs of failure. I have not opened the machine since it was last working, what could be the potential issues with this machine?
Generally in troubleshooting, go for the most obvious thing to try first. In this case, I would first remove and re-insert the hard drive to test the connection between the components, and secondarily connect a different hard drive (or preferably an SSD if you intend to keep the computer) and see if the computer detects it correctly. A main board failure is way down on the list of probable causes unless your computer has had liquid spilled into it or similar.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.