If 4.7" iPhone 6 never existed, would you upgrade to a 5.5" iPhone 6?

If 4.7" iPhone 6 never existed, would you get a 5.5" iPhone 6?

  • Yes

    Votes: 55 46.2%
  • No

    Votes: 64 53.8%

  • Total voters
    119

nlkccom

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Sep 18, 2008
850
875
I guess this question really gears toward the current iPhone 6 (not 6+) users.

What if the only options for an iPhone 6 is with the 5.5" screen. Would you still get an iPhone 6?
 

nouspa

macrumors member
Aug 20, 2014
50
7
I bought inferior product :)

It is even smallest storage size and silver, i just want to give unwanted phone a good home :)

I voted NO.
 

TSKY74

macrumors regular
Apr 14, 2012
118
0
Yes. I do love the 4.7 size and it's a good size for a phone, I would have taken the 5.5 If 4.7 wasn't available.
 

Hal~9000

macrumors 68020
Sep 13, 2014
2,031
1,798
What if the only options for an iPhone 6 is with the 5.5" screen. Would you still get an iPhone 6?
Emphatic NO!

I plan on keeping my 5s for 4-5 years until it no longer works but if I had to use something else I'd simply go Android (2013 moto x or 2014 z3 compact) for a one handed device instead of trying to lug around a mini-tablet ala 6+.
 
Last edited:

jettrue

macrumors regular
Nov 1, 2007
147
1
No, being a petite female, my hands and pockets are too small. Would have stayed with android.
 

ccapman670

macrumors regular
May 31, 2012
133
0
New Orleans / Baton Rouge
Nope. I would have sold my 5 and bought a 64GB 5S and ran it until it broke and if Apple didn't come out with something smaller I would decide whether I should go to android or just give up having a cell phone all together.
 

mojolicious

macrumors 68000
Mar 18, 2014
1,561
310
Sarf London
I've a terrible sense of déjà vu over this question :)

Absolutely not. Phones are simple communication devices, not mobile entertainment centres.
 

Kaylor

macrumors regular
Oct 18, 2011
212
127
Long Island, NY/Houston, TX
Probably not. Would've just stuck it out with my 5 for another year (which I might do anyway) to see if they released something smaller or if I could come to terms with such a big phone.
 

scottw324

macrumors 6502
Mar 5, 2012
452
1
I've a terrible sense of déjà vu over this question :)

Absolutely not. Phones are simple communication devices, not mobile entertainment centres.
Then you need to get rid of your Smartphone and go with a dumbphone for calls and basic text.

A Smartphone is just that, Smart. It allows you to communicate in multiple ways. Text, iMessage, email, phone calls, video calls, internet forums such as these, facebook, twitter, snapchat, and all the other ways that you all use social media to "communicate".

Not to mention, some of us want to use it for additional features so that we do not need to carry around multiple devices to do different things.

I loved my iP5 while I had used it but definitely wanted something bigger since I was tired of looking at a small screen. Most of the time I would switch to my rMini to read emails, internet sites, Kindle books, watch movies or TV shows, etc...

Then I upgraded to the 6+. Now I use my 6+ more than I use my rMini. I still break out the rMini for things like watching TV shows and movies, but I am perfectly ok with reading kindle books, internet websites, emails, etc.... on my 6+, which I was not on iP5.

If I had decided to get the 6 instead, who's to know. Maybe I would have been happy with that too but then again.

Let me put it this way, the only thing I lost so far with going with the 6+ model vs the 6 is taking it with me when I run. That isn't to say I may not take it later on, just at the moment I still use my iP5 or my old 2GB iPod Nano. I do find the 6+ a bit large to take for a jog at the moment but it meets all my other needs.

Not dogging the 6 model though since when/if I upgrade my wife's phone, that will definitely be the model she will get. I can't see her using and carrying around a plus model. She is happy at the moment with her iP5 in her Otterbox case so when she is ready to upgrade, maybe during the 6S cycle, we will.
 

mojolicious

macrumors 68000
Mar 18, 2014
1,561
310
Sarf London
Then you need to get rid of your Smartphone and go with a dumbphone for calls and basic text.

A Smartphone is just that, Smart. It allows you to communicate in multiple ways. Text, iMessage, email, phone calls, video calls, internet forums such as these, facebook, twitter, snapchat, and all the other ways that you all use social media to "communicate".
I do all of those (with the exceptions of those I don't). Perhaps I should have said 'simply' rather than simple'.
 

bambooshots

Suspended
Jul 25, 2013
1,414
2,889
Probably. I was leaning towards the 4.7" 6 until I ran across a website that gave the sizes of the devices on a 1:1 scale.

I realized the 5s with life proof case I've been using for the better part of a year was pretty much the same size as the 4.7" 6. I decided then that the 4.7" screen wouldn't be THAT much of an upgrade, and went with the 6 Plus instead.

Early *rumors* of the Plus havijg 2GB of RAM also swayed me in that direction, along with all of the confirmed specs over the 6 during the keynote.
 

mantan

macrumors 68000
Nov 2, 2009
1,707
953
DFW
I call BS. It's macrumors and an Apple product. People would claim it was flawless and superior to everything on the market. The perfect sized phone.
 

dvir971

macrumors regular
Feb 7, 2011
216
19
Israel
I will never go Android, never in my life. It became a personal issue for me.
Staying with my 5? This idea Won't work two years from now.
Buying Android? Nevah!
At some point I'll have to buy a new iPhone, even if it will be 6 inches
 
Last edited:

scottw324

macrumors 6502
Mar 5, 2012
452
1
I do all of those (with the exceptions of those I don't). Perhaps I should have said 'simply' rather than simple'.
Copy, cool beans.

The nice part about them is that each individual can use them how they see fit. My dad, still working on an old flip phone, but if I was to give him a smartphone, probably would still only use it for a phone. He doesn't text, wouldn't look at email on it since the text would be too small for him to read comfortably. But for me, hell, it is my run tracker, email, text, facebook, kindle, TV, GPS, etc... I could go on and on. For me it is indispensable.

With that said, sometimes one size does not meet everyones needs. I for one when with the 5.5" model. Love it! Some may want smaller phones/screens. Thats cool too. I like the 4.7" screen one as well, just didn't meet my needs as much as the 5.5" model.
 

dvir971

macrumors regular
Feb 7, 2011
216
19
Israel
It will work fine two years from now. Simply keep it on iOS 7 or 8 so the phone doesn't start to lag and get a battery replacement if needed.
No no no you misunderstood me :(
I didn't mean the phone would actually not work, I meant the idea won't work (I mean having a 2012 phone in 2016?). I'm sure the iPhone 5 will work perfectly fine in two years if I stay on iOS 7 as I intend to. I plan to buy the next model though
 

EdMan

macrumors 6502a
Oct 17, 2011
587
237
Michigan
I probably would have stuck with my 5 or would have bought the 5s. As a dedicated iPhone user from day 1 I still find the 6 Plus a little too big for everyday usage. I've never even played with Android so I can't speak intelligently about it but I may have taken a peak at some of their phones.
 

scottw324

macrumors 6502
Mar 5, 2012
452
1
It will work fine two years from now. Simply keep it on iOS 7 or 8 so the phone doesn't start to lag and get a battery replacement if needed.
Hell, I still have my old iPhone 3Gs at home. I use them as ipods now for my kids. They have some TV shows on them for the little one and some music on them for when we travel. My oldest has an iPad Mini in a griffin survivor case but there is no way in hell I am giving my youngest, 20 old something like that. She just likes making the screen light up. Sometimes she will sit still long enough to watch 5-10 mins of Dora. But if she breaks it, don't care. My iP5 I still have an probably will keep to use at home for media with the ATV3s in the house.
 

JulesK

macrumors 6502
Dec 17, 2002
467
54
I wouldn't; I'd stick with a 4" screen and get a retina iPad Mini

I'm thrilled with my iP6. I've held (barely) the iP6+ at the local Apple Store, and based on how I use my phone, I'd be dropping it frequently. Sure, if I had to I'd adopt, but I'm very used to using my phone one-handed and simply cannot with the iP6+. To me (but certainly not to others), it's a different category of device and not one that I want currently.

If I needed something really large for content consumption, I'd just get a retina iPad Mini.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.