Not to thread necro, but I recently ran into this thread again and I'm curious on those of you who have used the Artist version with both firm and standard tips. Which do you recommend? I'm getting one for drawing/painting purposes. I'm curious about the different applications of a firm vs standard tip. Also, are there durability differences? Thanks.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iFaraday stylus review: for those who dislike foam or rubber tipped styluses
- Thread starter oakie
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Not sure if you'll get a response from anyone who has used both but I'll add my comments with regard to the "extra firm" tip. It's my favorite stylus. I had thought I would prefer the Rx model because of its greater girth, but I keep coming back to the artist model.
As far as durability is concerned, I'd have to say after about 5 months, it shows no wear, whatsoever. I know some users find the tip too "flat" and as a result scrape the edge of the barrel against the iPad screen. I haven't found that to be the case but it probably depends upon one's writing style.
Where the "artist" model is especially useful, by the way, is in sketching applications (as distinguished from handwriting) where the thin, long barrel resembles the "feel" of a paintbrush. That may make it less suitable as a tool for writing but I've managed to adjust.
As far as durability is concerned, I'd have to say after about 5 months, it shows no wear, whatsoever. I know some users find the tip too "flat" and as a result scrape the edge of the barrel against the iPad screen. I haven't found that to be the case but it probably depends upon one's writing style.
Where the "artist" model is especially useful, by the way, is in sketching applications (as distinguished from handwriting) where the thin, long barrel resembles the "feel" of a paintbrush. That may make it less suitable as a tool for writing but I've managed to adjust.
I really have tried them all - used for presentations and drawing in presentations - the Faraday artist is my fav at this time. Like the adonits but they don't always land where I want them when presetting....
Thanks Glen, I've emailed them about the possibility of getting a white Artist Stylus made up. If not, I'd be interested in repainting. I am stuck on white!
Frankly, I think it may be because an early review of the "artist" model by an "artist" indicated he liked the extra firm tip. As a result I think a lot of us just ordered it based on that recommendation.
Since both of my iFaraday styluses have the "extra firm" tips, I can't compare them directly to the "standard" model but as I recall, the manufacturer recommended the extra firm for those who tend to press heavily on the screen when writing. The problem, as I recall, was that one could compress the tip sufficiently to make the edge of the barrel contact the screen.
There were some other problems early on with the first iFaraday styluses that may have contributed to the development of the "extra firm" tip. But I believe those issues were related to some low quality "substrate" materials that left smudges on the screen. To his credit, the manufacturer replaced all those with improved versions.
Bottom line: The manufacturer is extremely responsive to users' requirements. If you're not happy with his product, there have been a number of reports of his going several extra miles to satisfy his customers. I'd recommend his product without qualification.
----------
I can't compare them personally. Most of the reports I've read indicate the Bamboo stylus works very well. But frankly, after using about a half dozen different styluses I've come to the conclusion that one can make almost any of them work if you're prepared to invest the effort in practicing with them. Conversely, no stylus is going to improve your technique if the talent isn't there. (I know this because my sketching is just about as bad with one stylus as it is with another.
) The one advantage of the "artist" model for those are accustomed to a paint brush is that it is long and thin and "feels" more like a brush than the dimensions of the Bamboo stylus suggest.
I can't compare them personally. Most of the reports I've read indicate the Bamboo stylus works very well. But frankly, after using about a half dozen different styluses I've come to the conclusion that one can make almost any of them work if you're prepared to invest the effort in practicing with them. Conversely, no stylus is going to improve your technique if the talent isn't there. (I know this because my sketching is just about as bad with one stylus as it is with another.
The one advantage of the "artist" model for those are accustomed to a paint brush is that it is long and thin and "feels" more like a brush than the dimensions of the Bamboo stylus suggest.
Thanks, I am pretty well decided on this one. I like your remark about no stylus improving the technique, I guess I am hooped then
It makes me comfortable knowing that his service is excellent. I emailed the sales asking about the stock on the metallic blue, and also the possibility of getting a white one made. We'll see!!
Frankly, I think it may be because an early review of the "artist" model by an "artist" indicated he liked the extra firm tip. As a result I think a lot of us just ordered it based on that recommendation.
Since both of my iFaraday styluses have the "extra firm" tips, I can't compare them directly to the "standard" model but as I recall, the manufacturer recommended the extra firm for those who tend to press heavily on the screen when writing. The problem, as I recall, was that one could compress the tip sufficiently to make the edge of the barrel contact the screen.
There were some other problems early on with the first iFaraday styluses that may have contributed to the development of the "extra firm" tip. But I believe those issues were related to some low quality "substrate" materials that left smudges on the screen. To his credit, the manufacturer replaced all those with improved versions.
Bottom line: The manufacturer is extremely responsive to users' requirements. If you're not happy with his product, there have been a number of reports of his going several extra miles to satisfy his customers. I'd recommend his product without qualification.
----------
I can't compare them personally. Most of the reports I've read indicate the Bamboo stylus works very well. But frankly, after using about a half dozen different styluses I've come to the conclusion that one can make almost any of them work if you're prepared to invest the effort in practicing with them. Conversely, no stylus is going to improve your technique if the talent isn't there. (I know this because my sketching is just about as bad with one stylus as it is with another.
The one advantage of the "artist" model for those are accustomed to a paint brush is that it is long and thin and "feels" more like a brush than the dimensions of the Bamboo stylus suggest.
Thank you for the very informative post. Exactly the answer I was looking for. Guess I'll put in an order for the firm tip artist.
Just ordered one. The site says 2-3 days to ship and you should have within 7 business days. Guess like you I'll find out in the next week.
