Yeah..the funny thing is, i did try to contact him again after finding it was iClouded. As expected, I got no response.
This is my first (and hopefully LAST) time being scammed. I have to say, it feels pretty bad. :/
Umm... You weren't scammed. You agreed to trade a working phone for a broken phone... knowingly. Why you would want to do that is beyond comprehension, but you were not scammed. I'd say the guy on the other side of this was lucky to find someone like yourself that would trade for a broken phone, having no idea what was wrong with it.
On to new business... If you want another broken phone I have a beautiful 5s that won't power on that I'd be happy to sell you.