Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iMac or MacBook Pro 15"

M

macbanda

macrumors member
Original poster
Aug 22, 2008
79
2
I need a home computer - I currently have a 13" MacBook (black model). The computer would be used by my kids mainly to access the internet and some word processing.

I mainly use my computer for the same activities but plan on getting into some music recording - Pro Tools and Garage Band.

Would it make more sense to get a 21" iMac or a 15" replacement for my 13" inch and let my kids use the 13" inc with a bigger display? Is the MacBook pro more powerful than the iMac?

Lastly, I qualify for the education discount, where is the best place to buy the computer and save the most?

Thanks in advance,
 
Hi ,

Either one would be fine , however since you mentioned music production , I would go with the iMac.

Larger screen = easier to see and work with , if your going to be using Pro-Tools , you will appreciate the extra work space and clarity of the iMac.

If you just plan on GB , then a MacBook Pro 15" would be fine.

On a side note , I have been looking at MBP`s and I was thinking about the 17" , but after seeing the 15" and 17" side by side , the 15" looked clearer to me.

I even went so far has to change both to 1024 X 768 stretch and still the 15" was clearer , so native resolution is a reality !!

15" standard res would be my choice over the 17" __ IMO :)

Later ,

Gary 
 
Thank you Gary, I like the logic of the iMac over the MBP. Now, I love the size of the 27" but I'm wondering if it's overkill. My workspace area is relatively small. Any thoughts?



Jedi said:
Hi ,

Either one would be fine , however since you mentioned music production , I would go with the iMac.

Larger screen = easier to see and work with , if your going to be using Pro-Tools , you will appreciate the extra work space and clarity of the iMac.

If you just plan on GB , then a MacBook Pro 15" would be fine.

On a side note , I have been looking at MBP`s and I was thinking about the 17" , but after seeing the 15" and 17" side by side , the 15" looked clearer to me.

I even went so far has to change both to 1024 X 768 stretch and still the 15" was clearer , so native resolution is a reality !!

15" standard res would be my choice over the 17" __ IMO :)

Later ,

Gary 
Click to expand...
 
$1200 imac is a bit more powerful than $2200 MBP and has bigger screen.

MBP is portable. And the $2200 MBP model has more storage space actually. And you can upgrade the hard drive easier.

27" vs 21.5" imac depends on your preferences and wallet.
 
trip1ex said:
$1200 imac is a bit more powerful than $2200 MBP and has bigger screen.

MBP is portable. And the $2200 MBP model has more storage space actually. And you can upgrade the hard drive easier.

27" vs 21.5" imac depends on your preferences and wallet.
Click to expand...

The MBP is actually more powerful than the i5 iMacs, due to hyperthreading/turbo boost. The i7 iMacs win there though. That said, I'd still get the iMac, as it is plenty powerful and considerably cheaper.
 
I second the iMac for you and your families needs. More bang for the buck and a bigger screen for multi-media. Also, as the keyboard is separate from the computer so spilled drinks won't ruin the machine!
 
Thank you for the feedback :)

FuNGi said:
I second the iMac for you and your families needs. More bang for the buck and a bigger screen for multi-media. Also, as the keyboard is separate from the computer so spilled drinks won't ruin the machine!
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back