Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

nakile

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jun 30, 2007
151
0
I'm trying to decide right now, but I can't make up my mind.

At first the Macbook looked like a good idea. But I have a notebook right now as my primary system. It remains on my desk 24/7. I almost never move it and use it like a notebook should be used. So I thought that if this is the case, then I might as well get a iMac unit and get a larger screen, larger hard drive, full keyboard, dedicated video card, ect.

Then I started to think about why I do what I am doing with my notebook. It's because it's heavy, fat, hot, has a useless trackpad, an awful battery life, and super unreliable wireless. The Macbook seems to solve all these problems. I can't help but wonder that with none of these problems present with the Macbook that I would end up using it away from my desk more. It would be nice to go from place to place with a computer... and have it be useful unlike my current system. But I would still most likely never take it out of the house unless I go on one of my rare vacations.

The only real beef I have with the Macbook is the GMA 950. I do 3D computer graphics. Not like Pixar, but I do work with it in my free time. I have used systems with GMA 950s. They work, but it's kind of slow. Still, you can do quite a bit. Screen size is kind of a problem too, but I could adjust.

But then we have the rumors of a new Macbook with aluminum case and the Santa Rosa platform, meaning that without a doubt that the GPU will be the much superior GMA X3100, solving most of my 3D graphics problems.

So yeh, I'm real torn right now on what to get. What do you all think I should get? Macbook or iMac?
 
Get an iMac. The new ones are awesome and since you rarely bring it out, it's not a huge deal to walk to the other room to use the computer.
 
Sounds like you want an iMac. I own one and they are great. I thought I would regret having no portability, but it is nice to have such a big screen.
 
I got the MacBook simply because if I ever do want to bring it somewhere, I have that option.

Is this option important to you?
 
I got the MacBook simply because if I ever do want to bring it somewhere, I have that option.

Is this option important to you?
Kind of. It would be nice on a vacation. Although I really don't like to mess with technology when on a vacation. Rather just load up on a camera with a 1GB flash card and snap away.

So I guess it's iMac then. :p
 
Kind of. It would be nice on a vacation. Although I really don't like to mess with technology when on a vacation. Rather just load up on a camera with a 1GB flash card and snap away.

So I guess it's iMac then. :p

There you go. I am glad you are making the decision that is right for you.
 
I thought I would regret having no portability, but it is nice to have such a big screen.

well, according to your sig, you have a current revision MBP and a current revision MB to help ease that pain... :confused:

anyway, I'd say go imac. I wish I could sell my MB and get one, but I need a laptop for school for a while longer.
 
I owned a Powerbook from 2003-2006, then I decided that an iMac was the way to go; your right on vacation you dont need your laptop especially now with iPhone iPod touch ext. I love the added space on the HD and everything else on my iMac.
 
If you don't NEED the portability definitely go with the iMac. You won't regret it for a second.
 
I'm in college and have a powerbook because I travel a lot, move a lot, and my laptop leaves my desk at least 5 times a week. If I was more settled however, didn't move around so much, go to class etc, I would much rather prefer a fast and nicer to use iMac. If you really don't think you would use the portability, which it doesn't appear as such, and you don't want to spend the $$ for a desktop replacement like the 17" macbook pro, then get an iMac! They are awesome machines. My roommate does video editing on hers and I love using it sometimes because of it's speed and nice large screen and good bang for the buck.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.