It's really simple.
1 Drag in your music, trim the first ten seconds.
2 Drag in the music again after that, trim it to the other chunk
Done.
That's not really what I am talking about. I know you can do "trimming" or whatever they are calling it now. However, it is done in an entirely different interface which makes it much more difficult to sync/cut than it would in a timeline. Waveforms below the actual video is the best/easiest way to do this.
I'm not saying it may be as fast for you or that you will like it as much. I just take issue with saying "CAN'T BE DONE" which is flat out wrong.
If we're playing lawyerball I suppose I have to give there. Although I would liken it to being forced to use a stick and some twigs to start a fire when I used to have a perfectly good flamethrower for the same task. It can be done, but it's so inefficient that most people probably won't bother.
Or is your objection having to drag it in again? I don't see what the problem is since it's not like it makes another copy of the song or something.
It was fast and easy, now it's tedious and inefficient. That's the problem. All these extra steps and somehow it's heralded as easier. Selecting video in '08 is certainly easier. Audio, not so much.
And for the record, I haven't claimed that the dialogue box is faster and easier than rubberbanding (although your description isn't really accurate since rubberbanding usually requires creating points at the beginning and ends of the parts where you want to change the volume). I just dispute the false claim that you can't edit audio or set audio volumes.
That's for one global edit to any volume track. Wash, rinse, repeat the steps I listed for additional changes. So if you have a stretch of 10 clips over 10 seconds it's 2 clicks in '06 and 40 clicks in '08 (unless there is a select all that I have missed, and I sure hope that's the case). How is that easy?
I generally like 08, but there certainly is room for improvement. I hope they add more features, I think it's a nice interface and they can put some things back in without making it less intuitive and end up with a better app than 06. But in the meantime, I think it's pointless to be dishonest about what the app can do and insist that things are impossible when they clearly aren't.
I generally like it too. There are just some questionable design choices that I hope are remedied in point releases or something like an "iMovie Pro/Director's Cut". FCE doesn't fit this purpose and it's laughable that people are so quick to suggest that it does.