Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mark28

macrumors 68000
Original poster
It's perfect in the living room, but when covering very long distances it's just not as good.

Any solutions other than getting airport extreme?
 
I wonder why Wireless performance of Macbooks is so *****? My brother's crappy $200 netbook gets better signal on Wi-fi than my $2000 "N" powered Macbook Pro.
 
I wonder why Wireless performance of Macbooks is so *****? My brother's crappy $200 netbook gets better signal on Wi-fi than my $2000 "N" powered Macbook Pro.

It has a case made out of metal. MacBook Pros and PowerBooks have always had crap Wifi since going with metal cases. Sometimes, Apple has really stupid engineering. Like this, the iPhone 4, hockey puck mouse on first iMac, etc. Really sad. I seriously lay most of the blame Steve Jobs himself. He is notorious for putting form over function many a time. For another example, how about the razor-sharp wrist rests on the new MBP? Nice way to accidentally commit suicide I suppose. 🙄
 
I have no idea what some of you are saying.

My Time Warner connection is supposed to be 20 down, 2 up. I get 25 down and 1.7 up (Speedtest.net) for internet speeds. Pingtest.net confirms zero packet loss, 30ms ping, low jitter, a quality connection, as far as internet. Local LAN is a bit slow, but that's normal when you're working with 100% wireless devices.

One thing I don't have is wireless interference. My AP is isolated, the only wireless interfering device is the Wii, which isn't doing too much.

On my hotspot I also get decent speeds considering the hotspot itself.
 
I have no idea what some of you are saying.

My Time Warner connection is supposed to be 20 down, 2 up. I get 25 down and 1.7 up (Speedtest.net) for internet speeds. Pingtest.net confirms zero packet loss, 30ms ping, low jitter, a quality connection, as far as internet. Local LAN is a bit slow, but that's normal when you're working with 100% wireless devices.

One thing I don't have is wireless interference. My AP is isolated, the only wireless interfering device is the Wii, which isn't doing too much.

On my hotspot I also get decent speeds considering the hotspot itself.

what are YOU talking about?! the OP wants to increase the distance of his wireless network.
 
what are YOU talking about?! the OP wants to increase the distance of his wireless network.

What am I talking about? This:

MacBook Pros and PowerBooks have always had crap Wifi since going with metal cases.

I wonder why Wireless performance of Macbooks is so *****? My brother's crappy $200 netbook gets better signal on Wi-fi than my $2000 "N" powered Macbook Pro.

It's perfect in the living room, but when covering very long distances it's just not as good.

My response is effectively saying that my MacBook has experienced absolutely none of these issues so I have no idea what their origin is.
 
What am I talking about? This:



My response is effectively saying that my MacBook has experienced absolutely none of these issues so I have no idea what their origin is.

Try getting more distance from you AP. Wireless signal of the MBP will die where other notebooks will still be getting signal. I have seen it a lot.
 
Try getting more distance from you AP. Wireless signal of the MBP will die where other notebooks will still be getting signal. I have seen it a lot.

My router is 15 feet away. Solid signal. In the bedroom it becomes 30 feet. Still solid signal. I've gotten signal down the street from my apartment - 100 feet as the bird flies - still solid signal. Through walls, even with blatant interference from various devices (when I had them), still solid.

Again, I have not experienced this phenomenon. Then again I'm running a Belkin N+ router, so I imagine it's putting stuff out stronger than your average router.
 
My router is 15 feet away. Solid signal. In the bedroom it becomes 30 feet. Still solid signal. I've gotten signal down the street from my apartment - 100 feet as the bird flies - still solid signal. Through walls, even with blatant interference from various devices (when I had them), still solid.

Again, I have not experienced this phenomenon. Then again I'm running a Belkin N+ router, so I imagine it's putting stuff out stronger than your average router.
I have the same router, however I am never more than 20 feet from it. About to move into my dorm (t-minus 4 days) and we'll see how that router performs.
 
I have the same problem...I have the AE...when I'm downstairs it works great since its 20 or so feet away, but when I go upstairs...which is roughly 15 feet above it, connection goes down 1-2 bars...this is lame...
 
My router is 15 feet away. Solid signal. In the bedroom it becomes 30 feet. Still solid signal. I've gotten signal down the street from my apartment - 100 feet as the bird flies - still solid signal. Through walls, even with blatant interference from various devices (when I had them), still solid.

Again, I have not experienced this phenomenon. Then again I'm running a Belkin N+ router, so I imagine it's putting stuff out stronger than your average router.

You hava a 802.11N router. Of course the MBP will perform better since it has a N card. But Still sucks on "G" routers compared to other notebooks. That is my point, I have a G router, and N routers are not so popular yet. The places I use most are still stuck on the 802.11G technology.
 
You hava a 802.11N router. Of course the MBP will perform better since it has a N card. But Still sucks on "G" routers compared to other notebooks. That is my point, I have a G router, and N routers are not so popular yet. The places I use most are still stuck on the 802.11G technology.

Get a Mobile Hotspot. Then you don't have to worry about it at all.
 
I have a solution for my problem already. Im just saying that in my opinion/experience, Wireless of the MBP sucks.

Fixed. And in my experience, there's absolutely nothing wrong with the MBP's wireless when using the proper hardware.
 
Fixed. And in my experience, there's absolutely nothing wrong with the MBP's wireless when using the proper hardware.

I mean, compared to another cheaper notebooks. they usually have antennas on the extremities of the lid, and are made of plastic. Apple's solution can be beautiful, but its not that efficient.
 
People, you need to stop referring to wireless signals as "full signal" or "two bars." SNRs are far more useful and descriptive when determining who has a real issue and who doesn't.
 
Before I got my Airport Extreme, my only option was cantenna.

Just point them in the right direction and they will keep your from losing connection, if that's your problem.

picture1fy5.png
 
I mean, compared to another cheaper notebooks. they usually have antennas on the extremities of the lid, and are made of plastic. Apple's solution can be beautiful, but its not that efficient.

Dunno. I had worse issues keeping a signal with my old P7805u (full plastic and ugly to boot) than with my MacBook Pro. Guess it's definitely different strokes.


SNRs are far more useful and descriptive when determining who has a real issue and who doesn't.

Not when people don't know that SNR = signal noise reduction, which I would wager is the majority of those who would claim to experience the issue. Besides Mr. Gates, you of all people should know that sometimes you have to state things in terms the layman understands even if it's not "proper". Please...tune your antennas down a bit.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.