After returning my contour flick case (warning, it does not play well if you have an any type of clear plastic casing, like a bodygaurdz film, atleast mine didnt) I got the incase rubber case for the 3G. I was very impressed with the case, it fit great, and looked even better. After I took it off once to re-apply the plastic shields, the thin bottom part that is close to the home button ripped. Not happy, anyone else have this problem? Will they exchange it, it was less than 3 hours old and the company is closed now.