Incipio NGP Vs. Speck PixelSkin HD

[JMies419]

I have a Incipio NGP but was thinking about ordering a Speck PixelSkin HD for my iPhone 4s. My question is, how big of a difference is there between these two cases? If they are pretty much the same other than the design on the back of the PixelSkin I probably won't order it. Anyone have experiance with both and can speak about any big differences between the two or which they prefer? Thanks!

 

[k3roro]

Based on my experience using both cases, the PixelSkin HD felt nicer in the hands for me.

The lips for lay-on-table design for the PixelSkin HD is thinner than the Incipio NGP. The PixelSkin HD also felt wider and flatter than the Incipio NGP. The design on the back, while purefly for aesthecs

I prefer to the PixelSkin HD and during one time it was my favorite case.

 

[JMies419]

Based on my experience using both cases, the PixelSkin HD felt nicer in the hands for me.

The lips for lay-on-table design for the PixelSkin HD is thinner than the Incipio NGP. The PixelSkin HD also felt wider and flatter than the Incipio NGP. The design on the back, while purefly for aesthecs

I prefer to the PixelSkin HD and during one time it was my favorite case.

Do you have a screen protector on your phone? I have the power support crystal shields on mine, probably will bother them though, my NGP doesnt.

 

[andyx3x]

I have had the Incipio NGP case for my iPhone 4S. I found it VERY difficult to take on and off. Is this the same issue with the PixelSkin HD as well? Thanks!

No, the PixelSkin HD is very easy to take on and off. It's a rubber type case.

 

[k3roro]

Do you have a screen protector on your phone? I have the power support crystal shields on mine, probably will bother them though, my NGP doesnt.

I had screen protectors on my phone since Day 1, the Power Support Anti-Glare.

The screen protector didn't affect either cases.

 

[JMies419]

I had screen protectors on my phone since Day 1, the Power Support Anti-Glare.

The screen protector didn't affect either cases.

With the PixelSkin on the phone with the Power Support films, did the care seem to creak or make a sound when squeezing the sides of the phone?

 

[k3roro]

With the PixelSkin on the phone with the Power Support films, did the care seem to creak or make a sound when squeezing the sides of the phone?

When I had the Power Support Film on, the PixelSkin HD would sometimes make a sound when squeezing the sides of the phone. I'm a very picky person so I noticed this. If you were to ask other people they probably wouldn't even notice it.

I think it's just the internals of the PixelSkin HD rubbing against the side of the screen protector, you will feel something but it doesn't go as far as to lift your screen protector or bubble it.