MacSlut said:It has nothing to do with 7200rpm. As it is, 5400 rpm is too fast (noise, heat and wasted speed). The issue is with cost (3.5" is considerably cheaper per GB) and with capacity (even 500GB isn't enough for some of us...my media collection is well over 1.5TB). Sure there is FireWire and USB2, but the cool thing about a potential "mini a/v" is that it would be so convenient to take with you...and 3.5" versus 2.5" really won't increase the size much.
OMG, to think that this bad little boy could boot as a Windows PC, an OS X Mac, and replace my TiVo...Life could be good. Now, please, please, please, let this control common cable boxes, provide an "Apple-cool" programming guide via the Web, and let the files be open (for burning and transfer).
Keep it small. The number of mini's sold as desktop machines will far outstrip the number sold as media centres. If the mess with the form factor they'll lose what's beautiful about the mini.
I've picked up a mini as a headless server because of the size, and I'm already dreaming about how to make use of another.
As you said, the storage requirements for a videophile will exceed any drive they can put in there, so keep a couple firewire ports, but don't upset the core unit.
The 4GB nano is outselling the 60GB iPod even though there are some pretty loud voices here complaining that even 60GB isn't enough for them. The iPod can't be expanded, but the mini can-- look at things like the OWC mini-mate or whatever they call it (500GB drive and FW/USB hub that matches the mini footprint).
I'd expect Apple to follow the industry and their own history on this one as far as DRM: what you record yourself is yours, what you dowload from them is locked. Record your favorite shows, or pull them from iTMS if you didn't set it up, joined the series late, or just want it commercial free.