Switched from BodyGuardz to Invisible Shield
I was the person who posted some instructions on how to put on the BodyGuardz shield last year:
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/523209/
Now after that BodyGuardz shield has been on my iPhone 3G for a year, it is time to change it. I decided to give Invisible Shield a try. Why??? Here is why
1. The BodyGuardz film is very teeny tiny bit too big, such that the film protrudes above the bezel along one edge, and that two of the flaps at one corner overlap ever so slightly. Because of that the film tends to lift along those areas and dirt get underneath and they become detached for good.
2. The cut of the shield is such that it is not easy to get the corner to stay down, as I demonstrated in the above thread, I needed to pull some tricks.
I went to the Invisible Shield website to check out what they have to offer. I found the IS for iPhone 3G and that to my eyes the cut of the film is much better, which means I should have an easier time putting it on, I thus ordered the film and gave it a try.
Now that I've had IS on my iPhone 3G for a day, my initial impression is such that besides being
much easier to put on and get right, the IS skin is just not as good as the BodyGuardz skin. It has more of an orange peel effect, the paper backing sheet is of low quality such that it is difficult to remove, and it seems to pick up blemishes relatively easily.
After a few days I will probably put up some pictures and do a full report.