Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
All I want to do is ask Siri to play a song from Spotify on my Homepod without having to go through my iPhone. Seems like Spotify is not integrating this functionality yet however, so the ball is in their court.
 
  • Like
Reactions: flur
Still not working on macOS 11.3, although (promisingly?) Siri is now casting the blame on Spotify:

Screenshot 2021-04-27 at 08.37.14.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Websnapx2
Worked with my Deezer app yesssss
It changes everything for me and my airplay 2 setup! Finally!!!!
 
I had big hopes to play a song from Spotify on my HomePod Mini with Siri...It seems not possible still
 
Great feature! I know a lot of people have been asking for this, so I hope they are happy... shows Apple is paying attention.
No one has been asking for this. People have been asking for a choice of default music streaming service. This ain't it.
Why not just do this by default, but add a submenu for which one to play which type of content by default?

I don’t really understand the point either. If I want to listen to music I’ll say play music and the chosen default app would ideally be used. If I want to listen to a podcast I’d say play podcasts and again the default podcast app would be used. Or the only thing I use a lot of is audiobooks and I’d obviously ask Siri to play my audiobook.

They’re overthinking this one.
They aren't overthinking. They're being intentional. They don't want to offer users the choice of choosing a default streaming app, so they provide this half measure.
Does anyone know how to change the default player after the fact? It defaulted to Apple Music for mine and I want Spotify
You can't change it. It remains Apple Music. This is strictly a Siri interaction. From the article:
"However, Apple has since clarified that there isn't actually any option to choose a music service that will be selected on every occasion. More accurately, the feature in question uses ‌Siri‌ intelligence to learn from your listening habits and improve the music selection process over time."

Siri gets used to your choice over time and selects it. You have to use Siri though for it to work. AM is still your default.
 
If after you select an application, it remembers to use that application in the future, then how do you change it?
 
I had that problem. A restart cured it.
That usually works, for a day or two...

Siri asked me constantly which app to use during the beta test. I only have AppleMusic. Don’t know why it couldn’t “remember” to use that one app.
 
wow, this is a mess:

- asked for a podcast, was offered options that did not include Google Podcasts (no surprise, but still a stupid omission)
- told Siri to use apple podcasts app, and got the "something's gone wrong" error
- tried again, was shown the YouTube player with "Podcasts" in the top caption area (see attached)

So assuming this eventually gets sorted out, how can I change my preference for what Siri uses?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8920.PNG
    IMG_8920.PNG
    3.1 MB · Views: 76
  • Like
Reactions: Razorpit
We still need a 'I own my music, stop looking at services' option....
Where do you have your "own" music then? if it's still in the Music App, that's the app you choose. You're choosing to get hung up on semantics. I have a 25k album library and it all works perfectly exactly as described to get Siri to play my own music.
 
wow, this is a mess:

- asked for a podcast, was offered options that did not include Google Podcasts (no surprise, but still a stupid omission)
Google hasn't added the hooks into it for Siri. Those APIs have been available since iOS 12. Once they do the option will be available.
- told Siri to use apple podcasts app, and got the "something's gone wrong" error
Most likely because the Podcasts app got a major update and needed to update the library before it could actually play anything. I opened up the podcast app (manually) after the update and it took about 30 seconds to update my library before the new interface loaded and it was operational. That was most likely the issue there.
- tried again, was shown the YouTube player with "Podcasts" in the top caption area (see attached)
Due to my last point, because the Podcast app wasn't responding, it tried to offer something else up by way of general search, possibly related to your history but I could be wrong here. Either way, if it was not expected behavior, it's wrong behavior.
So assuming this eventually gets sorted out, how can I change my preference for what Siri uses?
The same instruction above applies.
 
YES 🙌. How about play music from my Library and stop pushing streaming services. I had to return my HomePod because of this lack of functionality. Anyone know if this was ever fixed..?
Nice to see that has been added.., now to change my playlist names to something Siri can easily handle!
This 'feature' hasn't 'been added', it has existed since the first iPhone. I use Siri to control my Music Library, and now my Spotify library as well.
 
I’m an Apple Music listener and Since this feature came in I tried it out using Spotify and back to Apple Music and now every time I ask Siri to play some music she asks which service to use

no matter how many times I say Apple Music over and over she won’t learn

this has fundamentally broken the way I use Siri and Apple Music

“hey Siri play my favourites mix”

“which service do you want to use?”

tap on Apple Music

“I can’t find anything called my favourites mix”

this used to work every time

I rephrase “play favourites mix”

she asks which service I tap Apple Music

“Playing favourites mix” 🤦🏻‍♂️
 
  • Sad
Reactions: srbNYC
Siri (and Voice Control) have always had this option.
I would so love to know how that works. I've been trying to find out how to have my Homepod mini default to my music library on my iMac. I don't subscribe to a music service as I don't want it. I had Apple Music for a number of years but it essentially destroyed my own music library. At one point, it somehow deleted all the track information (album,title, artists, etc.) from over a 1000 files. I have a ton of public domain files, project sound recordings, etc. And since none of those existed on Apple's service, their track information was purged.

It wasn't until I finally dropped the service that I was able to get control of a lot of those tracks again -- albeit over a long long period of time. But really, I would love to learn how to have my HomePod mini stop telling me tha it cannot find the recording I want it to play because it is trying to play it from Apple's music serivce. I just can't get it to point to my own iMac music library. Seems a very basic function to me.

I totaly dislike this recent push to drive Apple users to these online services all the time. I'm not interested in paying a monthly fee for things I don't need. Nor do I appreciate feeling like I'm being forced into it simply to get something to work the way it once did. Simply, and reliably. It seems once Job's left this planet, Apple has begun reverting to some of it's old tactics that got it into trouble in the 90s.
 
YES ?. How about play music from my Library and stop pushing streaming services. I had to return my HomePod because of this lack of functionality. Anyone know if this was ever fixed..?
Me damn too! I have this damn homepod mini and it is fast becoming nothing more than landfill. I don't have any interest in a service. I have tons of material of my own on my iMac. It's all just 0s and 1s... I cannot be convinced that in 2021 that Apple cannot simply make that happen. But, they are trying to force people into paying monthly fees for various cloud services, whether it is iCloud, Apple Music, Apple Books, etc., that is what this is all about.

I certainly miss Mr. Jobs. But no matter how messed up Apple might become, he won't be coming back to fix it this time. It would be in their best interest to stop behaving in the heavy handed way that Microcrap does.
 
“Sorry, something’s gone wrong. Please try again.”

Seems to work about as well as the rest of Siri.
Same here... I want to strangle that little bugger each time he replies with that. He' is about the size of a baseball and lucky for him I am not into repairing windows, else he would go flying right through it never to be seen or heard from again. :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.