As I have detailed in this thread:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2662084&tstart=0
My iPhone 4 has performed flawlessly since purchasing it almost 4 months ago, through 4.0.4.0.1 etc etc until 4.2.1 With the latter firmware I am finding sporadic 3G connectivity. When using an internet utilising app, say the integrated App Store app ("Updates"), or others like speedtest.net 8 out of 10 times or 9 out of 10 times it will be fine but in those 1-2 cases out of 10 it will take an inordinate amount of time and then kick out a network problem message from the app.
This is NOT a matter of my carrier having spotty 3G data connectivity (although Rogers have had it) nor is it a case of the particular celltower being at the time congested (I have duplicated this at 3:30 am and showing 3-5 bars). I know this is not the case as I am still able to switch back to 4.1 as I have on my hard drive the 4.1 GM which I happened to download a few days before the release of 4.1. The 4.1 GM is identical to the release version.
Anyhow, with (using Windows) shift + restore I have shifted back and forth between 4.1 and 4.2.1 about a dozen times. Not once have I had these problems with 4.1 as I am having with 4.2.1
I have done everything with 4.2.1. I have reset network settings, reset all settings, restored the software, restored as a new phone not using any backups whatsoever, Done 2 DFU restores (via slightly different methods) and always the same result. I have sporadic 3G network issues which I *never* had before which could not be put at the door of Rogers.
Clearly this is not a widespread problem - definitely not as widespread as the Wifi issue in iPad and iPhone apple forums. Nevertheless, a lot more people than those reporting it on the apple forums have this problem without knowing it. They simply are not noticing the issues and probably blaming their carrier. A good example is my neighbour who lives in the same apartment building as I do and who has an iPhone 4 also with Rogers and has updated to 4.2.1. When I saw him in the lobby I asked him if he had any issues with 4.2.1 and he said no. I asked him if I could try out his phone and he gave it to me. I was able to duplicate this issue in a few minutes on his phone.