Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Having tried a number of readers, I liked MobileRSS the best, especially now that the iPad version came out.

Pulse and Early Edition are solid apps and great looking. But my own opinion is, if I wanted great looking, I would just open up Safari and go to the web sites directly. The reason we get RSS apps is to do a news digest sort of thing. Too many CPU cycles into generating the look instead of just downloading the articles. MobileRSS is a simple, fast app that has a bunch of features.

But for me, a major issue was with how the web was accessed inside the RSS app. A lot of times, you need to go to the web site directly to see the article content since the RSS feed can sometimes be just a headline and not give anough info. Some apps, like Pulse and Early Edition, have a problem with accessing web sites inside their own app if the link is designed to open up as a "new" page by launching a new window or tab (from the perspective of if you were on a conventional browser).

They work OK if the link is designed to open the new page in the same existing window or tab. But if the link tries to open as a new tab or window, those RSS feeders won't open those types of pages - nothing will happen when you click the "outside" links. MobileRSS and Reeder will work with those coded kinds of pages OK, though Reeder doesn't have an iPad version yet.

It sounds pretty obscure, but for me at least, this issue comes up quite a bit.
 
^^It's a difficult choice sometimes and I find myself using two b/c of some of the things you mentioned. I have grown to like NewsRack but I'm going to give MobileRSS HD a chance.
 
^^It's a difficult choice sometimes and I find myself using two b/c of some of the things you mentioned. I have grown to like NewsRack but I'm going to give MobileRSS HD a chance.

i switched from
NewsRack to MobileRSS HD and it is better in every way. my vote goes to MobileRSS HD
 
Do any of these readers have an option to download the actual stories along with the RSS Headline? I need to read the news on the bus and don't want to have to use 3G for that. I want to "sync" before I leave and then have access when I am not connected.
 
Do any of these readers have an option to download the actual stories along with the RSS Headline? I need to read the news on the bus and don't want to have to use 3G for that. I want to "sync" before I leave and then have access when I am not connected.

You may want to look at Instapaper Pro for that. It does an outstanding job when needing off line information.
 
i switched from
NewsRack to MobileRSS HD and it is better in every way. my vote goes to MobileRSS HD

I just made the change from NewsRack to MobileRSS last night. It was a tough decision. NewsRack was really nice and I had NO complaints about it what-so-ever. I had used MobileRSS on my iPhone though and loved it.

Glad I made the switch. MobileRSS doesn't really function any better....but it sure is pretty....amazinly so. Can't wait for the rest of the features to be updated. The dev...in my experience....has been very quick to update and respond to questions.

Steve
 
Originally Posted by PCClone
Do any of these readers have an option to download the actual stories along with the RSS Headline? I need to read the news on the bus and don't want to have to use 3G for that. I want to "sync" before I leave and then have access when I am not connected.

You may want to look at Instapaper Pro for that. It does an outstanding job when needing off line information.

Early Edition has an option to send to instapaper for offline reading. The best of both worlds. Instapaper is pretty amazing. When I first saw it, I thought how is this usefull? Boy was I wrong!
 
Early Edition has an option to send to instapaper for offline reading. The best of both worlds. Instapaper is pretty amazing. When I first saw it, I thought how is this usefull? Boy was I wrong!

I totally agree, I had no idea not long ago what Instapaper was all about till I took the time to see. It's a must have App as far as I'm concerned. It's that good. I highly recommend it to anyone.

There will aways be black out zones and it's nice to have that during those times we are in a black out.

I've posted my thoughts on MobileRSS HD and NewsRack in the iPad App thread.

Post #23

.
 
Pulse was pulled from the App Store I guess. I couldn't find the thread on Pulse RSS App so I thought I would use this thread to pass the info along.

Linky

I was lucky and downloaded it before being pulled.

Bummer :(
 
Pulse was pulled from the App Store I guess. I couldn't find the thread on Pulse RSS App so I thought I would use this thread to pass the info along.

Linky

I was lucky and downloaded it before being pulled.

Bummer :(

it was pulled because the NYT said it violated their rules since it was a paid app. They are removing the NYT feed and then it will be available again.
 
Do any of these readers have an option to download the actual stories along with the RSS Headline? I need to read the news on the bus and don't want to have to use 3G for that. I want to "sync" before I leave and then have access when I am not connected.

You should use Instapaper for viewing offline.
Pulse, however, has a web view toggle (but doesn't cache for offline).
 
Pulse is my new fave, here's hoping that they cache feeds soon, as I'm not always at an area with wifi (or I don't want to or am too lazy to run my MyWi ;))
 
Reeder looks very nice but, when reading in landscape mode, is there any way to get rid of the left panel that has the list of articles it it so that the full screen width (minus the button/tool bar) can be used to view the item that is currently being read?

- Julian
 
Reeder looks very nice but, when reading in landscape mode, is there any way to get rid of the left panel that has the list of articles it it so that the full screen width (minus the button/tool bar) can be used to view the item that is currently being read?

I don't know if there is a way to do it as you suggest. However if you tap the upper-right button and select the Instapaper Mobilizer, you can read it full screen. I know it isn't the same as what you're asking for, but it will go full screen.
 
Offline, my pulse app shows just a blank page with all my feed names and none of the articles... Maybe I'm just doing something wrong.

You probably aren't doing anything wrong. I have 3G and haven't been offline yet. I wonder if it's something they are going to work into Pulse. If you want offline caching, you may want to have Reeder or NewsRack around for that.
 
Reeder iPad App

Speaking of Reeder iPad App, can someone possibly post what the Instapaper or Google Stablizer does? I've always noticed it with a few different Apps but never really understood what it does or how it helps.

When I was looking over the Reeder RSS App I noticed those are on by default where others have been off by default.

I have not noticed any difference with it being on or off.
 
Speaking of Reeder iPad App, can someone possibly post what the Instapaper or Google Stablizer does? I've always noticed it with a few different Apps but never really understood what it does or how it helps.

When I was looking over the Reeder RSS App I noticed those are on by default where others have been off by default.

I have not noticed any difference with it being on or off.

It sends the article to Instapaper service which stores an offline text view of it for you. You can come back to it anytime with Instapaper app or their web site. It's useful for downloading long articles that you don't want to read via GReader as well as downloading text view only.

There's no Stablizer, I think you meant Mobilizer. It converts the original site into a mobile friendly site.
 
Mobilizer (Instapaper or Google) is triggered by pressing the Services button from within the article view screen. That's the button with the arrow. Or, holding down any link on the screen will eventually bring up the Services panel. It then routes that web link to Google or Instapaper to convert it to a more mobile-friendly page. I personally don't like the look of that kind of page, so I've turned the Mobilizers off.

If you do like it, Reeder has a setting to allow all links to go through that Mobilizer process.
 
Speaking of Reeder iPad App, can someone possibly post what the Instapaper or Google Stablizer does? I've always noticed it with a few different Apps but never really understood what it does or how it helps.

From Instapaper: "Browse the web from mobile devices using Instapaper's Text view to save bandwidth, reduce loading times, and optimize pages for small screens." http://www.instapaper.com/extras

It sends the article to Instapaper service which stores an offline text view of it for you. You can come back to it anytime with Instapaper app or their web site. It's useful for downloading long articles that you don't want to read via GReader as well as downloading text view only.

this is what "save to Instapaper" is, and just appears in Reeder as "Instapaper" in the upper-right.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.